Birkeland K, Furevik J, Bøe O E, Wisth P J
Department of Orthodontics and Facial Orthopedics, University of Bergen, Norway.
Eur J Orthod. 1997 Jun;19(3):279-88. doi: 10.1093/ejo/19.3.279.
To assess the outcome of orthodontic treatment, 224 cases treated in a postgraduate clinic were evaluated. Pre-treatment (T1), post-treatment (T2) and 5-year follow-up (T3) study casts were assessed by the Peer Assessment Rating (PAR) Index. The influence of various factors upon treatment and long-term outcome was analysed. According to the PAR Index, orthodontic treatment reduced the malocclusions on average by 76.7 per cent, and at follow-up the reduction was 63.8 per cent. Follow-up stability was good for 76.3 per cent of the cases. Some cases (4.0 per cent) even improved, while moderate to severe post-treatment relapse occurred in 19.7 per cent of the cases. Orthodontic treatment changed Angle Class I, II and III malocclusions to near ideal occlusion (PAR scores 4.4-6.8). No long-term interaction between the groups was discovered. Sex and extraction/non-extraction treatments did not significantly affect the results. The initial PAR score accounted for 77.8 per cent of the variation in treatment PAR score change (T1-T2), and for 61.8 per cent of the variation of long-term PAR score change (T1-T3). Age at treatment start accounted significantly for the variability of treatment changes (P < 0.001). The PAR score at the end of treatment had some explanatory importance (R2 = 0.099) for the long-term (T1-T3) result. However, PAR score changes in the follow-up period were difficult to predict.
为评估正畸治疗的效果,对在研究生诊所接受治疗的224例患者进行了评估。采用同伴评估等级(PAR)指数对治疗前(T1)、治疗后(T2)以及5年随访(T3)的研究模型进行评估。分析了各种因素对治疗及长期效果的影响。根据PAR指数,正畸治疗平均将错牙合畸形减少了76.7%,随访时减少了63.8%。76.3%的病例随访稳定性良好。部分病例(4.0%)甚至有所改善,而19.7%的病例出现了中度至重度的治疗后复发。正畸治疗将安氏I类、II类和III类错牙合畸形转变为接近理想的牙合关系(PAR评分4.4 - 6.8)。未发现组间的长期相互作用。性别以及拔牙/不拔牙治疗对结果无显著影响。初始PAR评分占治疗PAR评分变化(T1 - T2)变异的77.8%,占长期PAR评分变化(T1 - T3)变异的61.8%。开始治疗时的年龄对治疗变化的可变性有显著影响(P < 0.001)。治疗结束时的PAR评分对长期(T1 - T3)结果有一定的解释意义(R2 = 0.099)。然而,随访期的PAR评分变化难以预测。