Hill S L, Holtzman G L, Berry R, Arnold J F
Department of Surgery, Carilion Roanoke Community Hospital, Virginia, USA.
Am Surg. 1997 Aug;63(8):720-5.
The duplex scan has become the definitive test in the diagnosis of carotid arterial disease. Its significance, however, has been diminished its extensive use for inappropriate indications. We performed a retrospective study over a four year period at two major hospitals to evaluate the different indications for carotid duplex scans. Symptoms which prompted the test, associated diseases, the type of physician ordering the test, and demographic data were recorded on all patients. Statistical analysis was used to indicate which symptoms and associated diseases were significant in predicting carotid disease. A total of 4,764 scans were reviewed. There were 4,289 studies (90%) which were negative for disease requiring surgery. There were a total of 12 indications for the carotid duplex scan in this study; the most common indications were dizziness, (20%) transient ischemic attack symptoms (19%) and a bruit (16%). Vascular surgeons (28%), Internal Medicine physicians (27%) and Family practice physicians (15%) ordered the duplex scan most frequently, but 39% of the positive scans were ordered by vascular surgeons. A history of seizures, confusion, stroke and as a preoperative evaluation all had a very low yield and should not be used as an indication for a duplex scan. However, a long smoking history, a history of known carotid disease, and peripheral vascular disease all had a statistical correlation with an abnormal duplex scan. The use of the duplex scan to rule out carotid arterial disease for patients with vague, uncommon symptoms is inappropriate and wasteful.
