Khan K, Roberts P, Nattrass C, Bennell K, Mayes S, Way S, Brown J, McMeeken J, Wark J
Department of Medicine, University of Melbourne, Royal Melbourne Hospital, Australia.
Clin J Sport Med. 1997 Jul;7(3):174-9. doi: 10.1097/00042752-199707000-00004.
To report range of motion at the hip and ankle in male and female ballet dancers compared with controls.
Cross-sectional cohort study with convenience control sample.
National classical ballet school in Australia.
Thirty-three female and 30 male full-time ballet students of mean (SD) age 16.9 (0.8) and 18.0 (1.4) years, respectively. Controls were 31 female and 16 male nondancing, normally active university students of average ages 18.8 +/- 0.6 and 18.8 +/- 0.9 years, respectively.
Degrees of range of motion of left and right sides for the following four movements: standing plié in parallel-passive ankle dorsiflexion (DF), standing turnout in the balletic first position-lower limb external rotation (LLER), supine hip external rotation (ER), supine hip internal rotation (IR). Two additional ranges of motion were calculated. External rotation below the hip joint (BHER) was derived by subtracting hip ER from LLER, and total supine hip rotation (Hip IR + ER) was derived by summing hip ER and hip IR.
On both left and right sides, dancers had greater LLER (p < 0.0001) and hip ER (p < 0.0001) but lesser hip IR than the controls (p < 0.0001). Female but not male dancers had greater total supine hip rotation (hip ER+IR) than controls (p < 0.05). There was no difference in either BHER or ankle DF between dancers and controls. Within dancers, females had greater range in both left and right hip IR, LLER, and hip IR + ER. There was no difference in hip ER. Regression analysis revealed that LLER related to hip ER in both males and females.
Elite classical dance students had greater hip external rotation (both ER and LLER) and less hip internal rotation than controls but similar BHER and ankle DF. Since ER below the hip joint and ankle DF do not differ between dancers and controls, despite repeated training of these movements in ballet, there may be anatomical (bony/ligamentous) limitations to these movements.
报告男性和女性芭蕾舞舞者与对照组相比,髋关节和踝关节的活动范围。
采用便利对照样本的横断面队列研究。
澳大利亚国立古典芭蕾舞学校。
33名女性和30名男性全日制芭蕾舞学生,平均(标准差)年龄分别为16.9(0.8)岁和18.0(1.4)岁。对照组为31名女性和16名男性不跳舞的、正常活动的大学生,平均年龄分别为18.8±0.6岁和18.8±0.9岁。
以下四种动作左右侧的活动范围度数:平行站立蹲姿 - 被动踝关节背屈(DF)、芭蕾舞第一位置站立外开 - 下肢外旋(LLER)、仰卧位髋关节外旋(ER)、仰卧位髋关节内旋(IR)。还计算了另外两个活动范围。髋关节以下外旋(BHER)通过从LLER中减去髋关节ER得出,仰卧位髋关节总旋转(髋关节IR + ER)通过将髋关节ER和髋关节IR相加得出。
在左右两侧,舞者的LLER(p < 0.0001)和髋关节ER(p < 0.0001)均大于对照组,但髋关节IR小于对照组(p < 0.0001)。女性而非男性舞者的仰卧位髋关节总旋转(髋关节ER + IR)大于对照组(p < 0.05)。舞者与对照组之间的BHER或踝关节DF均无差异。在舞者中,女性左右髋关节IR、LLER以及髋关节IR + ER的活动范围更大。髋关节ER无差异。回归分析显示,男性和女性的LLER均与髋关节ER相关。
优秀的古典舞学生髋关节外旋(ER和LLER)大于对照组,髋关节内旋小于对照组,但BHER和踝关节DF相似。由于尽管在芭蕾舞中对这些动作进行了反复训练,但舞者与对照组之间髋关节以下的ER和踝关节DF并无差异,因此这些动作可能存在解剖学(骨骼/韧带)限制。