Paquette D W, Fiorellini J P, Martuscelli G, Oringer R J, Howell T H, McCullough J R, Reasner D S, Williams R C
Department of Periodontics, University of North Carolina School of Dentistry, Chapel Hill, USA.
J Clin Periodontol. 1997 Aug;24(8):521-8. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-051x.1997.tb00223.x.
Systemic and topical administration of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) has been shown to reduce periodontal disease progression in both animal models and human subjects. Our present research focuses on single enantiomers of these agents to examine whether enantiospecific therapy will be efficacious in slowing periodontitis. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the inhibitory effects of (S)-ketoprofen on experimentally induced alveolar bone loss in beagle dogs. 16, 18-month-old, female beagles were brought to optimal periodontal health over a 2-week pretreatment period. Experimental periodontitis was then induced by placing silk ligatures around premolar and molar teeth and by instituting a soft, plaque-promoting diet. At baseline, animals were randomized to 1 of 4 groups, consisting of 2x daily administration of (1) placebo dentifrice, (2) 0.3% (S)-ketoprofen dentifrice, (3) 3.0% (S)-ketoprofen dentifrice, or (4) 10.0 mg (S)-ketoprofen capsules (p.o.) over a 60 day treatment period. Standardized, periapical radiographs exposed at days 1 and 60 were analyzed by computer-assisted digital radiography in order to assess the rate of alveolar bone loss. Secondary outcomes included technetium 99m-tin-diphosphonate (99mTc-Sn-MDP) uptake and the gingival index. At baseline, no differences were observed among the groups for linear bone height or 99mTc-Sn-MDP uptake ratios. From days 1 to 60, cohorts differed significantly in terms of bone loss rates (p < 0.001). In particular, beagles treated with systemic or topical (S)-ketoprofen (0.3% or 3.0% dentifrices) exhibited significantly lower mean rates of bone loss compared to placebo treated beagles (p < 0.05). Group differences in mean radiopharmaceutical uptake ratio changes approached significance (ANOVA, p = 0.07), where animals treated with topical 0.3% (S)-ketoprofen demonstrated a reduction and other groups demonstrated elevations over the 60-day dosing period. Treatment cohorts did differ significantly with respect to changes in mean gingival indices (p < 0.05). Animals treated with 0.3% or 3.0% (S)-ketoprofen dentifrice exhibited significantly reduced elevations in gingival index scores as compared to placebo treated animals. These data provide evidence that enantiospecific therapy with (S)-ketoprofen, topically or systemically delivered, may alter the progression of periodontal disease in the beagle dog model.
在动物模型和人类受试者中,非甾体抗炎药(NSAIDs)的全身和局部给药均已显示可减缓牙周病进展。我们目前的研究聚焦于这些药物的单一对映体,以检验对映体特异性疗法在减缓牙周炎方面是否有效。本研究的目的是评估(S)-酮洛芬对实验性诱导的比格犬牙槽骨丧失的抑制作用。16只18月龄的雌性比格犬在为期2周的预处理期内达到最佳牙周健康状态。然后通过在双尖牙和磨牙周围放置丝线结扎并采用促进菌斑形成的软食来诱导实验性牙周炎。在基线时,将动物随机分为4组中的1组,在60天的治疗期内,每组每天2次给予:(1)安慰剂牙膏;(2)0.3%(S)-酮洛芬牙膏;(3)3.0%(S)-酮洛芬牙膏;或(4)10.0 mg(S)-酮洛芬胶囊(口服)。在第1天和第60天拍摄的标准化根尖片通过计算机辅助数字放射摄影进行分析,以评估牙槽骨丧失率。次要结局包括99m锝-锡-二膦酸盐(99mTc-Sn-MDP)摄取和牙龈指数。在基线时,各组之间在骨线性高度或99mTc-Sn-MDP摄取率方面未观察到差异。从第1天到第60天,各组在骨丧失率方面存在显著差异(p < 0.001)。特别是,与接受安慰剂治疗的比格犬相比,全身或局部给予(S)-酮洛芬(0.3%或3.0%牙膏)治疗的比格犬平均骨丧失率显著降低(p < 0.05)。平均放射性药物摄取率变化的组间差异接近显著水平(方差分析,p = 0.07),其中局部给予0.3%(S)-酮洛芬治疗的动物在60天给药期内摄取率降低,而其他组升高。治疗组在平均牙龈指数变化方面确实存在显著差异(p < 0.05)。与接受安慰剂治疗的动物相比,用0.3%或3.0%(S)-酮洛芬牙膏治疗的动物牙龈指数评分升高明显降低。这些数据提供了证据,表明局部或全身给予(S)-酮洛芬的对映体特异性疗法可能改变比格犬模型中牙周病的进展。