The primary surgical treatment of carcinoma of the breast: a changing trend toward modified radical mastectomy.

To study the effectiveness of a trend at the Mayo Clinic toward modifying the standard radical mastectomy, the 5-year survival of 873 women treated surgically for breast cancer from 1965 through 1968 was evaluated. The observed survival of 534 patients treated by the standard radical mastectomy was 85% when nodes were negative and 56% when nodes were positive. For 339 patients treated by the modified radical mastectomy, the observed survival was 80% and 48% when axillary nodes were negative and positive, respectively. In order to accomplish a more significant analysis of cancer risk and results of the two operative procedures, a relatively homogeneous group of 541 patients was established from the total group. In this homogeneous group, the observed survival of 336 patients treated by the standard radical mastectomy was 86% when nodes were negative and 66% when nodes were positive. For 205 patients treated by the modified radical mastectomy, the observed survival was 84% and 66% when axillary nodes were negative and positive, respectively. When patients were further analyzed and compared according to the extent of axillary-node involvement, age at the time of treatment, grade, size, location, and histopathologic type of tumor, and the use of postoperative irradiation, survival was essentially the same, irrespective of the type of mastectomy performed.