Jørgensen H S, Nakayama H, Raaschou H O, Olsen T S
Department of Neurology, Bispebjerg Hospital, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Neurology. 1997 Nov;49(5):1335-42. doi: 10.1212/wnl.49.5.1335.
Medical treatment of acute stroke with tissue plasminogen activator (tPA) was recently approved in the United States, and neuroprotective agents are being developed. Should all patients with stroke, regardless of severity, receive such treatment? In the Copenhagen Stroke Study we studied the prognosis of stroke in 1,351 unselected patients from a well-defined catchment area treated in a community-based stroke unit from the time of acute admission to death or the end of rehabilitation. Outcome measures were mortality, discharge rates to the patients' own home or to a nursing home, length of hospital stay, and neurological and functional outcomes. Prognosis was stratified according to initial stroke severity measured by the Scandinavian Neurological Stroke Scale (SSS) on admission. We estimated the effect of medical treatment on prognosis and health care utilization by assuming a medically induced decrease in initial stroke severity by 5 and 10 points in the initial SSS score. This mild and moderate decrease in initial stroke severity corresponded to an overall improvement in outcome and an overall cost reduction through shorter hospital stays. This was also true in patients with both mild and moderate stroke. However, in patients with severe stroke, survival increases expenses because of an increased discharge rate to a nursing home and an increase in the cost of acute care and rehabilitation. Future medical stroke trials should therefore focus on the effect and cost of treatment, especially in patients with severe stroke, and search for factors predictive of good clinical outcome in this group.
组织型纤溶酶原激活剂(tPA)用于急性中风的药物治疗最近在美国获得批准,并且神经保护剂也正在研发中。所有中风患者,无论严重程度如何,都应该接受这种治疗吗?在哥本哈根中风研究中,我们研究了1351名来自明确集水区的未经过挑选的患者的中风预后情况,这些患者在社区中风单元接受治疗,从急性入院到死亡或康复结束。结果指标包括死亡率、出院回家或养老院的比例、住院时间以及神经和功能预后。根据入院时通过斯堪的纳维亚神经中风量表(SSS)测量的初始中风严重程度对预后进行分层。我们通过假设初始SSS评分因医疗干预而降低5分和10分来估计药物治疗对预后和医疗保健利用的影响。初始中风严重程度的这种轻度和中度降低对应于结果的总体改善以及通过缩短住院时间实现的总体成本降低。轻度中风和中度中风患者也是如此。然而,在重度中风患者中,由于转至养老院的出院率增加以及急性护理和康复成本增加,存活会增加费用。因此,未来的中风医学试验应关注治疗的效果和成本,尤其是在重度中风患者中,并寻找该组中预测良好临床结果的因素。