Codine P, Bernard P L, Pocholle M, Benaim C, Brun V
Service de Reeducation Fonctionnelle, Hôpital Lapeyronié, Montpellier, France.
Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1997 Nov;29(11):1400-5. doi: 10.1097/00005768-199711000-00002.
Isokinetic shoulder rotational strength was evaluated in four groups of subjects as follows: 12 nonathletes, 12 runners, 15 tennis players, and 12 baseball players for a total of 51 subjects. The tests were performed in the seated 45 degrees abducted test position in the scapular plane at 60, 180, and 300 degrees.s-1 for both shoulders. Peak torque and mean power values were gathered, and from these values the internal/external rotation ratios were calculated. Intergroup comparison showed a progression of the ratio related to the sports discipline. The nonathletes and runners had ratios close to those reported for nonathletes (1.3 to 1.5). The tennis players had ratios close to 1.5, whereas the baseball players had ratios from 1.6 to 2.2. The comparison between dominant and nondominant side showed no significant differences in the tennis players and higher values for the dominant side in the nonathletes and runners under certain conditions (180 degrees.s-1 for the nonathletes and 300 degrees.s-1 for the runners). Regarding the baseball players, the ratio was systematically higher for the dominant side. These results raise questions about the influence of sports discipline on the internal/external rotator muscle ratio and indicate the need to establish normative values based on the characteristics of the population under study.
12名非运动员、12名跑步者、15名网球运动员和12名棒球运动员,共计51名受试者。测试在肩胛平面内45度外展的坐姿测试位置进行,双肩均在60、180和300度/秒的速度下进行。收集峰值扭矩和平均功率值,并根据这些值计算内/外旋转比率。组间比较显示该比率与运动项目有关。非运动员和跑步者的比率接近非运动员报告的比率(1.3至1.5)。网球运动员的比率接近1.5,而棒球运动员的比率为1.6至2.2。优势侧与非优势侧的比较显示,网球运动员两侧无显著差异,非运动员和跑步者在某些条件下(非运动员为180度/秒,跑步者为300度/秒)优势侧的值更高。对于棒球运动员,优势侧的比率系统性更高。这些结果引发了关于运动项目对等速内/外旋转肌比率影响的疑问,并表明需要根据所研究人群的特征建立标准值。