Rubin J W, Killam H A, Moore H V, Ellison R G
Ann Thorac Surg. 1976 Jul;22(1):74-9. doi: 10.1016/s0003-4975(10)63956-2.
Our total pacemaker experience was evaluated to determine survival, complications, effectiveness of follow-up techniques, and future goals for surveillance. A retrospective review of 287 patients with 570 pulse generators revealed 164 alive and 104 dead; 3 recovered normal conduction, 14 transferred care, and 2 have been lost to follow-up. Average age at initial implantation was 67 years. Overall mean generator life has been 22 months. The one-, three-, five-, and ten-year survival is 84, 71, 60, and 39%, respectively. The 738 operations performed averaged 2.6 procedures per patient. Of the total survivors, 108 (66%) had no complications; 56 (34%) have had at least one complication, 70% during the first year of the initial implantation. Fifty episodes of premature interruption of pacing service were detected. Ninety-one patients (32% of the group) have required an operative procedure on their pacemaker system more frequently than every two years. Of the replacements, 89 (29%) were for reasons other than end of generator life; 66 (63%) of the deaths occurred before replacement of the first generator. Mortality in the first two years was 23%. Once survival exceeded two years the average annual death rate was 3.7% (expected, 3.2%). Survival in our series compares favorably with that of other groups who report by the actuarial method. These data suggest that some deaths, reduced patient productivity, and the high cost to health care providers may be due in part to inadequate follow-up after the first pacemaker implantation. If follow-up observation is done frequently during the first year after initial implantation and once minimum generator longevity has passed, the goals of pacemaker therapy may be achieved.
我们对整个起搏器植入经验进行了评估,以确定生存率、并发症、随访技术的有效性以及未来监测目标。对287例患者植入的570台脉冲发生器进行回顾性研究,结果显示164例存活,104例死亡;3例恢复正常传导,14例转诊,2例失访。首次植入时的平均年龄为67岁。总的来说,脉冲发生器的平均使用寿命为22个月。1年、3年、5年和10年生存率分别为84%、71%、60%和39%。共进行了738次手术,平均每位患者接受2.6次手术。在所有存活患者中,108例(66%)无并发症;56例(34%)至少出现过一次并发症,其中70%发生在首次植入后的第一年。共检测到50次起搏服务过早中断。91例患者(占该组的32%)需要每两年对起搏器系统进行一次以上的手术操作。在更换的脉冲发生器中,89台(29%)并非因使用寿命结束而更换;66例(63%)死亡发生在首次更换脉冲发生器之前。前两年的死亡率为23%。一旦存活超过两年,平均年死亡率为3.7%(预期为3.2%)。我们系列研究中的生存率与其他采用精算方法报告的组相比具有优势。这些数据表明,部分死亡、患者生产力下降以及医疗服务提供者的高成本可能部分归因于首次植入起搏器后的随访不足。如果在首次植入后的第一年经常进行随访观察,并且一旦达到最低脉冲发生器寿命,起搏器治疗的目标可能会实现。