Kelly J A, Murphy D A, Sikkema K J, McAuliffe T L, Roffman R A, Solomon L J, Winett R A, Kalichman S C
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Medicine, Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee 53226, USA.
Lancet. 1997 Nov 22;350(9090):1500-5. doi: 10.1016/s0140-6736(97)07439-4.
Community-level interventions may be helpful in population-focused HIV prevention. If members of populations at risk of HIV infection who are popular with other members can be engaged to advocate the benefits of behaviour change to peers, decreases in risk behaviour may be possible. We assessed a community-level intervention to lower the risk of HIV infection, focusing on men patronising gay bars in eight small US cities.
We used a randomised community-level field design. Four cities received the intervention and four control cities did not. Participants were men from each city who went to gay bars. Men completed surveys about their sexual behaviour on entering the bars during 3-night periods at baseline and at 1-year follow-up. In the control cities, HIV educational materials were placed in the bars. In the intervention cities, we recruited popular homosexual men in the community and trained them to spread behaviour-change endorsements and recommendations to their peers through conversation.
Population-level of risk behaviour decreased significantly in the intervention cities compared with the control cities at 1-year follow-up, after exclusion of surveys completed by transients and men with exclusive sexual partners in a city-level analysis, in the intervention cities we found a reduction in the mean frequency of unprotected anal intercourse during the previous 2 months (baseline 1.68 occasions; follow-up 0.59: p = 0.04) and an increase in the mean percentage of occasions of anal intercourse protected by condoms (baseline 44.7%; follow-up 66.8%, p = 0.02). Increased numbers of condoms taken from dispensers in intervention-city bars corroborated risk-behaviour self-reports.
Popular and well-liked members of a community who systematically endorse and recommend risk-reduction behaviour can influence the sexual-risk practices of others in their social networks. Natural styles of communication, such as conversations, brought about population-level changes in risk behaviour.
社区层面的干预措施可能有助于以人群为重点的艾滋病病毒预防工作。如果能让受其他成员欢迎的艾滋病病毒感染风险人群成员参与进来,向同龄人宣传行为改变的益处,那么风险行为或许有可能减少。我们评估了一项社区层面的干预措施,以降低艾滋病病毒感染风险,该措施主要针对美国八个小城市中光顾同性恋酒吧的男性。
我们采用了随机社区层面实地设计。四个城市接受干预,四个对照城市不接受。参与者是来自每个城市且光顾同性恋酒吧的男性。男性在基线期和1年随访期的三个晚上进入酒吧时,完成关于其性行为的调查。在对照城市,在酒吧放置艾滋病病毒教育材料。在干预城市,我们招募社区中受欢迎的同性恋男性,并培训他们通过交谈向同龄人传播行为改变的支持意见和建议。
在1年随访时,与对照城市相比,干预城市的人群层面风险行为显著降低。在城市层面分析中,排除由暂住者和在同一城市有固定性伴侣的男性完成的调查后,在干预城市,我们发现前两个月无保护肛交的平均频率有所降低(基线时为1.68次;随访时为0.59次:p = 0.04),且使用避孕套进行肛交的平均比例有所增加(基线时为44.7%;随访时为66.8%,p = 0.02)。干预城市酒吧中从避孕套分发器取用的避孕套数量增加,证实了风险行为自我报告的情况。
社区中受欢迎且受喜爱的成员系统性地支持并推荐降低风险行为,可影响其社交网络中其他人的性风险行为。自然的沟通方式,如交谈,带来了人群层面风险行为的改变。