Wernicke J F, Sayler M E, Koke S C, Pearson D K, Tollefson G D
ELLYN Inc., League City, Texas, USA.
Depress Anxiety. 1997;6(1):31-9.
Concomitant use of psychoactive medications is a common practice in most clinical trials of antidepressant medications. However, the relative therapeutic impact of such use on trial results has not been the subject of much attention. We conducted a meta-analysis to determine whether concomitant use of psychoactive medications confounded the efficacy or safety results of a series of fluoxetine trials. Data were evaluated from 25 randomized, double-blind clinical trials comparing fluoxetine with placebo or a tricyclic antidepressant (TCA) in 4,016 patients with major depression. We compared incidence rates of concomitant use of anxiolytics, sedatives, and antipsychotics between treatments. In addition, we compared the change in total score for the 21-Item Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HAMD21): incidence rates of any worsening, emergence, or improvement in psychomotor agitation; and incidence of suicidal acts and any worsening, emergence, or improvement in suicidal ideation between treatment groups among patients taking/not taking a sedative. Anxiolytic and antipsychotic drug use was uncommon (8.3% and 0.9% overall use, respectively) and did not substantially increase over time. Sedative drugs were used most often (29.6% overall), but only 29.8% of the fluoxetine-treated patients took one or more doses. Regarding efficacy, fluoxetine was superior to placebo in decreasing HAMD21 total scores among patients taking/not taking sedatives. Effects on safety were assessed by examining agitation and suicidal ideation. Use of sedatives did not affect the change in the HAMD agitation score; scores were similar in patients receiving fluoxetine, placebo, and TCAs. In all treatment groups, anxiolytic use tended to increase as the HAMD anxiety score increased. Fluoxetine was superior to placebo in treating suicidal ideation, and the concomitant use of sedatives did not influence this effect. Overall, concomitant use of psychotropic medications in the fluoxetine depression clinical trials was uncommon. Our meta-analysis demonstrated that the clinical efficacy and safety of fluoxetine were not confounded by the concomitant use of medications.
在大多数抗抑郁药物的临床试验中,同时使用精神活性药物是一种常见的做法。然而,这种使用对试验结果的相对治疗影响并未受到太多关注。我们进行了一项荟萃分析,以确定同时使用精神活性药物是否会混淆一系列氟西汀试验的疗效或安全性结果。对25项随机、双盲临床试验的数据进行了评估,这些试验在4016名重度抑郁症患者中比较了氟西汀与安慰剂或三环类抗抑郁药(TCA)。我们比较了各治疗组之间同时使用抗焦虑药、镇静剂和抗精神病药的发生率。此外,我们比较了21项汉密尔顿抑郁量表(HAMD21)总分的变化:精神运动性激越任何恶化、出现或改善的发生率;以及在服用/未服用镇静剂的患者中,各治疗组之间自杀行为的发生率以及自杀观念的任何恶化、出现或改善情况。抗焦虑药和抗精神病药的使用并不常见(总体使用率分别为8.3%和0.9%),且并未随时间大幅增加。镇静药物使用最为频繁(总体使用率为29.6%),但仅29.8%接受氟西汀治疗的患者服用了一剂或多剂。在疗效方面,无论患者是否服用镇静剂,氟西汀在降低HAMD21总分方面均优于安慰剂。通过检查激越和自杀观念来评估对安全性的影响。镇静剂的使用并未影响HAMD激越评分的变化;接受氟西汀、安慰剂和TCA治疗的患者评分相似。在所有治疗组中,随着HAMD焦虑评分的增加,抗焦虑药的使用倾向于增加。氟西汀在治疗自杀观念方面优于安慰剂,同时使用镇静剂并未影响这一效果。总体而言,在氟西汀抑郁症临床试验中同时使用精神药物并不常见。我们的荟萃分析表明,氟西汀的临床疗效和安全性并未因同时使用药物而受到混淆。