Cataldo M G, Brancato D, Brancato G, Verga S, Buscemi S, Licata G
Insegnamento di Gastroenterologia, Università degli Studi di Palermo.
Ann Ital Med Int. 1997 Jan-Mar;12(1):15-9.
The aim of this study was to verify if there is a 1:2 correlation between subcutaneous adipose tissue thickness measured by ultrasonography and skinfold caliper and if this correlation varies in function of the degree of obesity, subcutaneous fat thickness, and the area evaluated. Forty women (age 27.9 +/- 11.7 years, body mass index 28.75 +/- 5.40 Kg/m2, waist to hip ratio 0.77 +/- 0.06) underwent ultrasonographic measurement of subcutaneous adipose tissue and skinfold caliper measurement at nine different sites (bicipital, tricipital, subscapular, suprailiac, epigastric umbilical, hypogastric, gluteal, and femoral). Data analysis confirmed a significant correlation between measurements made by ultrasonography and skinfold plicometry at all sites when the patients were not subdivided according to body mass index or skinfold thickness. When they were subdivided on the basis of body mass index, a significant correlation was found for subjects with a body mass index < 30; when the index was > 30, the correlation was observed at only the subscapular and suprailiac sites, and to a lesser degree at the tricipital and femoral sites. Moreover, a highly significant correlation was found only at sites at which ultrasonographic thickness was not > 20 mm (p < 0.001) with an r value decreasing progressively from 0.685 (thickness < 10 mm) to 0.248 (thickness > 40 mm). Given the great variability of this correlation, we suggest that ultrasonography is preferable to plicometry for the measurement of fat.
本研究的目的是验证超声测量的皮下脂肪组织厚度与皮褶厚度计测量结果之间是否存在1:2的相关性,以及这种相关性是否会因肥胖程度、皮下脂肪厚度和评估部位的不同而有所变化。40名女性(年龄27.9±11.7岁,体重指数28.75±5.40kg/m²,腰臀比0.77±0.06)在九个不同部位(肱二头肌、肱三头肌、肩胛下、髂嵴上、脐上腹部、脐下腹部、臀、股部)接受了皮下脂肪组织的超声测量和皮褶厚度计测量。数据分析证实,当不根据体重指数或皮褶厚度对患者进行细分时,超声测量和皮褶测量在所有部位的测量结果之间存在显著相关性。当根据体重指数进行细分时,体重指数<30的受试者存在显著相关性;当指数>30时,仅在肩胛下和髂嵴上部位观察到相关性,在肱三头肌和股部部位的相关性较小。此外,仅在超声测量厚度不>20mm的部位发现高度显著相关性(p<0.001),r值从0.685(厚度<10mm)逐渐降至0.248(厚度>40mm)。鉴于这种相关性的巨大变异性,我们建议在测量脂肪时,超声检查比皮褶测量更可取。