Alarcon G, Garcia Seoane J J, Binnie C D, Martin Miguel M C, Juler J, Polkey C E, Elwes R D, Ortiz Blasco J M
Institute of Epileptology, King's College, London, UK.
Brain. 1997 Dec;120 ( Pt 12):2259-82. doi: 10.1093/brain/120.12.2259.
Although acute electrocorticography (ECoG) is routinely performed during epilepsy surgery there is little evidence that the extent of the discharging regions is a useful guide to tailoring the resection or that the findings are predictive of outcome or pathology. Patterns of discharge propagation have, however, rarely been considered in assessing the ECoG. We hypothesize that regions where discharges show earliest peaks ('leading regions') are located in the epileptogenic zone, whereas sites in which late, secondary, propagated activity occurs have less epileptogenic potential and do not need to be excised. To allow intraoperative topographic ECoG analysis, a computer program has been developed to identify leading regions and the sites showing greatest rates or amplitudes of spikes. Their topography has been compared retrospectively with pathology and seizure control in 42 consecutive patients following temporal lobe surgery. Leading regions were most often found in the hippocampus, the subtemporal cortex and the superior temporal gyrus. The most common propagation patterns were from hippocampus to subtemporal cortex and vice versa. There was no association between seizure outcome and the location of regions with greatest incidence or amplitude of spikes or location of leading regions. There was, however, a strong and significant association between poor outcome and non-removal of leading regions other than those in the posterior subtemporal cortex. All leading regions (other than posterior subtemporal) were resected in 27 patients of whom 25 had a favourable outcome. Leading regions (other than posterior subtemporal) remained in 14 patients of whom only four had a good outcome. One patient had no epileptiform activity in the ECoG and good outcome. Persistent posterior subtemporal leading regions remained in nine subjects; all had favourable outcome (Grades I or II) but only three were seizure free. These results suggest that: (i) interictal epileptiform discharges may originate from a complex interaction between separate regions, resulting in propagation and recruitment of neuronal activity along specific neural pathways; (ii) removal of all discharging areas appears unnecessary to achieve seizure control provided that leading regions (other than posterior subtemporal) are removed; and (iii) identification of such leading regions could be used to tailor resections in order to improve seizure control and reduce neurological, neuropsychological and psychiatric post-surgical morbidity.
尽管在癫痫手术期间常规进行急性皮质脑电图(ECoG)检查,但几乎没有证据表明放电区域的范围对确定切除范围有用,也没有证据表明这些发现可预测手术结果或病理情况。然而,在评估ECoG时,很少考虑放电传播模式。我们假设放电最早出现峰值的区域(“领先区域”)位于致痫区,而出现晚期、继发性、传播性活动的部位致痫潜力较小,无需切除。为了进行术中地形图ECoG分析,已开发出一个计算机程序来识别领先区域以及显示最高棘波发生率或幅度的部位。对42例颞叶手术后的患者,将这些区域的地形图与病理情况及癫痫控制情况进行了回顾性比较。领先区域最常出现在海马体、颞下皮质和颞上回。最常见的传播模式是从海马体到颞下皮质,反之亦然。癫痫发作结果与棘波发生率或幅度最高的区域位置或领先区域位置之间没有关联。然而,除颞下后部区域外,未切除领先区域与预后不良之间存在强烈且显著的关联。27例患者切除了所有领先区域(颞下后部区域除外),其中25例预后良好。14例患者保留了领先区域(颞下后部区域除外),其中只有4例预后良好。1例患者的ECoG中无癫痫样活动且预后良好。9例患者保留了持续的颞下后部领先区域;所有患者预后良好(I级或II级),但只有3例无癫痫发作。这些结果表明:(i)发作间期癫痫样放电可能源于不同区域之间的复杂相互作用,导致神经元活动沿特定神经通路传播和募集;(ii)只要切除领先区域(颞下后部区域除外),似乎无需切除所有放电区域即可实现癫痫控制;(iii)识别此类领先区域可用于调整切除范围,以改善癫痫控制并降低术后神经、神经心理和精神方面的发病率。