Shaw F E, Kenny R A
Department of Medicine (Geriatric Medicine), Royal Victoria Infirmary, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK.
Postgrad Med J. 1997 Oct;73(864):635-9. doi: 10.1136/pgmj.73.864.635.
Syncope and falls are often considered to be two separate diagnoses with two separate sets of aetiologies. However, although it remains controversial, the existence of an overlap between syncope and falls is becoming increasingly acknowledged. In the elderly, determining the cause of a fall can be difficult. Approximately 30% of cognitively normal elderly people are unable to recall documented falls three months later and a witness account for syncopal events is unavailable in about 50% of patients. We have found that in almost 40% of patients in whom an attributable diagnosis of carotid sinus syndrome was made, the only presenting symptoms were falls alone or falls with dizziness; syncope was denied. Amnesia for loss of consciousness can be demonstrated in over 20% of all patients with a diagnosis of carotid sinus syndrome and in 50% of those patients who present only with falls or falls and dizziness. There is a suggestion from studies in postprandial hypotension and orthostatic hypotension, where similar haemodynamic changes are found in patients complaining of either syncope or falls, that this phenomenon may be generalisable. The importance of the presence of an overlap between syndrome and falls in the elderly lies in the healthcare implications of missed diagnoses of cardiovascular syncope for which there are established effective treatments. Consideration of syncope in the differential diagnosis of unexplained falls should reduce the numbers of falls for which no attributable diagnosis is found and result in an improved standard of health care for elderly patients who fall.
晕厥和跌倒通常被认为是两种不同的诊断,病因也各不相同。然而,尽管仍存在争议,但晕厥和跌倒之间存在重叠这一现象正越来越受到认可。对于老年人来说,确定跌倒的原因可能很困难。约30%认知正常的老年人在三个月后无法回忆起有记录的跌倒事件,约50%的患者没有晕厥事件的目击者描述。我们发现,在几乎40%被诊断为颈动脉窦综合征的患者中,唯一的症状表现就是单纯跌倒或跌倒伴头晕;否认有晕厥症状。在所有诊断为颈动脉窦综合征的患者中,超过20%的患者以及50%仅表现为跌倒或跌倒伴头晕的患者存在意识丧失后的失忆情况。在餐后低血压和体位性低血压的研究中发现,抱怨晕厥或跌倒的患者存在相似的血流动力学变化,这表明这种现象可能具有普遍性。老年人中综合征和跌倒之间存在重叠的重要性在于,对于有既定有效治疗方法的心血管性晕厥漏诊所带来的医疗影响。在不明原因跌倒的鉴别诊断中考虑晕厥因素,应该会减少找不到可归因诊断的跌倒数量,并提高跌倒老年患者的医疗保健水平。