Widén Holmqvist L, von Koch L, Kostulas V, Holm M, Widsell G, Tegler H, Johansson K, Almazán J, de Pedro-Cuesta J
Division of Neurology, Karolinska Institute, Huddinge University Hospital, Stockholm, Sweden.
Stroke. 1998 Mar;29(3):591-7. doi: 10.1161/01.str.29.3.591.
This study describes the methodology, patient outcome, and use of hospital and rehabilitation services at 3 months of a population-based randomized controlled trial. The purpose was to evaluate rehabilitation at home after early supported discharge from the Department of Neurology, Huddinge Hospital, for moderately disabled stroke patients in southwest Stockholm.
The patients were eligible if they were continent, independent in feeding, had mental function within normal limits, and had impaired motor function and/or aphasia 1 week after stroke. Patients were randomized either to early supported discharge with continuity of rehabilitation at home for 3 to 4 months or to routine rehabilitation service in a hospital, day care, and/or outpatient care. The home rehabilitation team consisted of two physical therapists, two occupational therapists, and one speech therapist; one of the therapists was assigned as case manager for the patient. The rehabilitation program at home emphasized a task- and context-oriented approach. The activities were chosen on the basis of the patient's personal interests. Spouses were offered education and individual counseling. A total of 81 patients were followed up for a minimum of 3 months. Patient outcome was assessed by the Frenchay Social Activity Index, Extended Katz Index, Barthel Index, Lindmark Motor Capacity Assessment, Nine-Hole Peg Test, walking speed over 10 m, reported falls, and subjective dysfunction according to the Sickness Impact Profile. Patient use of hospital and home rehabilitation service and patient satisfaction with care were studied.
Overall there were no statistical significant differences in outcome. Multivariate logistic regression analysis suggested a systematic positive effect for the home rehabilitation group in social activity, activities of daily living, motor capacity, manual dexterity, and walking. A considerable difference in resource use during such a 3-month period was seen. A 52% reduction in hospitalization was observed: from 29 days in the routine rehabilitation group to 14 days in the home rehabilitation group. Patient satisfaction was in favor of the latter group.
Early supported discharge with continuity of home rehabilitation services for the majority of moderately disabled stroke patients during the first 3-month period after acute stroke is not less beneficial than routine rehabilitation and can be a rehabilitation service of choice if follow-up at 6 and 12 months confirms the suggested effectiveness and considerable reduction in use of health care.
本研究描述了一项基于人群的随机对照试验在3个月时的方法、患者结局以及医院和康复服务的使用情况。目的是评估在胡丁厄医院神经科对斯德哥尔摩西南部中度残疾中风患者进行早期支持出院后在家中的康复情况。
患者若在中风1周后能自主控制大小便、独立进食、精神功能正常且存在运动功能障碍和/或失语,则符合入选标准。患者被随机分为两组,一组接受早期支持出院并在家中持续康复3至4个月,另一组接受医院、日间护理和/或门诊的常规康复服务。家庭康复团队由两名物理治疗师、两名职业治疗师和一名言语治疗师组成;其中一名治疗师被指定为患者的个案管理员。家庭康复计划强调以任务和情境为导向的方法。活动根据患者的个人兴趣选择。为配偶提供教育和个别咨询。共有81名患者接受了至少3个月的随访。通过法国ay社会活动指数、扩展Katz指数、Barthel指数、Lindmark运动能力评估法、九孔插钉试验、10米步行速度、报告的跌倒情况以及根据疾病影响概况得出的主观功能障碍来评估患者结局。研究了患者对医院和家庭康复服务的使用情况以及患者对护理的满意度。
总体而言,结局方面无统计学显著差异。多变量逻辑回归分析表明,家庭康复组在社会活动、日常生活活动、运动能力、手部灵活性和步行方面有系统性的积极影响。在这3个月期间,资源使用存在显著差异。观察到住院时间减少了52%:从常规康复组的29天降至家庭康复组的14天。患者满意度倾向于后一组。
对于大多数中度残疾中风患者,在急性中风后的前3个月内进行早期支持出院并持续提供家庭康复服务,其益处并不低于常规康复,并且如果6个月和12个月的随访证实了所提示的有效性以及医疗保健使用的显著减少,那么这可以成为一种康复服务选择。