Rigotti N A, Arnsten J H, McKool K M, Wood-Reid K M, Pasternak R C, Singer D E
Tobacco Research and Treatment Center Unit, Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Medical School, Boston 02114, USA.
Arch Intern Med. 1997;157(22):2653-60.
Hospitalization may be an opportune time to change smoking behavior because it requires smokers to abstain from tobacco at the same time that illness can motivate them to quit. A hospital-based intervention may promote smoking cessation after discharge.
We tested the efficacy of a brief bedside smoking counseling program in a randomized controlled trial at Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston. The 650 adult smokers admitted to the medical and surgical services were randomly assigned to receive usual care or a hospital-based smoking intervention consisting of (1) a 15-minute bedside counseling session, (2) written self-help material, (3) a chart prompt reminding physicians to advise smoking cessation, and (4) up to 3 weekly counseling telephone calls after discharge. Smoking status was assessed 1 and 6 months after hospital discharge by self-report and validated at 6 months by measurement of saliva cotinine levels.
One month after discharge, more intervention than control patients were not smoking (28.9% vs 18.9%; P=.003). The effect persisted after multiple logistic regression analyses adjusted for baseline group differences, length of stay, postdischarge smoking treatment, and hospital readmission (adjusted odds ratio, 2.19; 95% confidence interval, 1.34-3.57). At 6 months, the intervention and control groups did not differ in smoking cessation rate by self-report (17.3% vs 14.0%; P=.26) or biochemical validation (8.1% vs 8.7%; P=.72), although the program appeared to be effective among the 167 patients who had not previously tried to quit smoking (15.3% vs 3.7%; P=.01).
A low-intensity, hospital-based smoking cessation program increased smoking cessation rates for 1 month after discharge but did not lead to long-term tobacco abstinence. A longer period of telephone contact after discharge might build on this initial success to produce permanent smoking cessation among hospitalized smokers.
住院可能是改变吸烟行为的一个契机,因为这要求吸烟者在患病期间戒烟,而疾病可能促使他们产生戒烟的动机。基于医院的干预措施可能会促进出院后戒烟。
我们在波士顿的麻省总医院进行了一项随机对照试验,以测试简短床边吸烟咨询项目的效果。650名入住内科和外科病房的成年吸烟者被随机分配接受常规护理或基于医院的吸烟干预,该干预包括:(1)15分钟的床边咨询;(2)书面自助材料;(3)提醒医生建议患者戒烟的图表提示;(4)出院后最多3次每周的咨询电话。出院后1个月和6个月通过自我报告评估吸烟状况,并在6个月时通过测量唾液可替宁水平进行验证。
出院后1个月,不吸烟的干预组患者多于对照组(28.9%对18.9%;P = 0.003)。在对基线组差异、住院时间、出院后吸烟治疗及再次入院情况进行多因素逻辑回归分析调整后,该效果仍然存在(调整后的优势比为2.19;95%置信区间为1.34 - 3.57)。6个月时,干预组和对照组通过自我报告的戒烟率没有差异(17.3%对14.0%;P = 0.26),通过生化验证的戒烟率也没有差异(8.1%对8.7%;P = 0.72),不过该项目在167名此前未尝试戒烟的患者中似乎有效(15.3%对3.7%;P = 0.01)。
一个低强度、基于医院的戒烟项目提高了出院后1个月的戒烟率,但未导致长期戒烟。出院后更长时间的电话联系可能在这一初步成功的基础上,使住院吸烟者实现永久戒烟。