Crapo P A, Reaven G, Olefsky J
Diabetes. 1976 Sep;25(9):741-7.
We have studied the effects of glucose, sucrose, and various starches on postprandial plasma glucose and insulin responses in 19 subjects. All carbohydrate loads were calculated to contain 50 gm. of glucose, and the response to each carbohydrate was tested twice: when given alone in a drink or when given in combination with other nutrients as a meal. The data demonstrate: (1) Glucose and sucrose elicited similar plasma glucose response curves, but sucrose elicited a somewhat greater (20 per cent) plasma insulin response. (2) Raw starch ingestion resulted in a 44 per cent lower glucose response and a 35-65 per cent lower insulin response than did either glucose or sucrose ingestion. (3) When carbohydrate was given as a meal the plasma glucose responses were 40-60 per cent lower than when the same carbohydrate was given as a drink, while the insulin responses were generally similar, and (4) when different cooked starches were compared, the plasma glucose and insulin responses to rice were significantly lower (50 per cent) than to potato. In conclusion, the size of the carbohydrate molecule appears to influence the postprandial glucose and insulin responses such that more complex carbohydrates (starches) elicit lower responses. This effect may be related to differences in digestion rather than to differences in absorption.
我们研究了葡萄糖、蔗糖和各种淀粉对19名受试者餐后血浆葡萄糖和胰岛素反应的影响。所有碳水化合物负荷量经计算均含50克葡萄糖,且对每种碳水化合物的反应均测试两次:单独以饮料形式给予时,以及与其他营养素一起作为一餐给予时。数据表明:(1) 葡萄糖和蔗糖引起的血浆葡萄糖反应曲线相似,但蔗糖引起的血浆胰岛素反应略高(20%)。(2) 与摄入葡萄糖或蔗糖相比,摄入生淀粉导致的葡萄糖反应降低44%,胰岛素反应降低35% - 65%。(3) 当碳水化合物作为一餐给予时,血浆葡萄糖反应比以饮料形式给予相同碳水化合物时低40% - 60%,而胰岛素反应通常相似;(4) 当比较不同的熟淀粉时,大米引起的血浆葡萄糖和胰岛素反应比土豆显著低(50%)。总之,碳水化合物分子的大小似乎会影响餐后葡萄糖和胰岛素反应,使得更复杂的碳水化合物(淀粉)引起的反应更低。这种效应可能与消化差异而非吸收差异有关。