Ciaroni S, Bloch A, Cuenoud L, Fournet P C
Service de cardiologie, Hôpital de la Tour, Meyrin-Genève.
Schweiz Med Wochenschr. 1998 Mar 14;128(11):400-8.
It has been demonstrated that the ratio of the systolic blood pressure post-exercise to that at peak exercise (rSBP) is a criterion for diagnosis and severity of coronary artery disease (CAD) in men. No such demonstration has been attempted in women. We have compared SBP to classical signs of ischemia, such as ST segment depression and angina pectoris, in a group of 788 ambulatory patients of whom 357 were women. All underwent a bicycle ergometric test and a coronary angiogram. The prevalence of CAD at angiography was the same for both genders (women 43.5% and men 47%) with no significant difference in the number of vessels diseased. In patients with CAD, the rSBP was significantly more elevated than in others, at 1 minute (p < 0.01) and even more so at 3 minutes (p < 0.001) post-exercise, with no gender difference. The most discriminating value of rSBP at 3 minutes post-exercise for diagnosis of CAD was situated at 0.91 for sensitivity and specificity (receiver operating characteristic curve analysis). In the whole group sensitivity of rSBP is lower, while the specificity is greater than classical criteria of ischemia. The sensitivity of rSBP is poor for the diagnosis of single vessel disease, but of equal value compared to ST segment depression in the presence of multivessel disease, with no gender difference. The specificity of rSBP is higher than ST segment depression in women (p < 0.001) compared to men (p < 0.05). rSBP has a positive correlation with the number of coronary vessels diseased but not with the extent of ST segment depression. Our study demonstrates that rSBP at 3 minutes post-exercise is a less good diagnostic sign than the classical criteria of myocardial ischemia. However, rSBP has good specificity, particularly in women, thus reducing false positive tests related to ST segment depression. rSBP is also a marker of the severity of coronary artery disease.
研究表明,运动后收缩压与运动峰值时收缩压的比值(rSBP)是男性冠状动脉疾病(CAD)诊断及病情严重程度的一项标准。但尚未对女性进行过此类研究验证。我们对788例门诊患者(其中357例为女性)的收缩压与缺血的经典体征(如ST段压低和心绞痛)进行了比较。所有患者均接受了自行车测力计测试和冠状动脉造影。血管造影显示CAD在两性中的患病率相同(女性为43.5%,男性为47%),病变血管数量无显著差异。在CAD患者中,运动后1分钟时rSBP显著高于其他患者(p<0.01),运动后3分钟时更是如此(p<0.001),且无性别差异。运动后3分钟时rSBP对CAD诊断的最具鉴别力的值,其敏感性和特异性为0.91(受试者操作特征曲线分析)。在整个研究组中,rSBP的敏感性较低,而特异性高于缺血的经典标准。rSBP对单支血管病变的诊断敏感性较差,但在多支血管病变时与ST段压低具有同等价值,且无性别差异。与男性相比(p<0.05),女性中rSBP的特异性高于ST段压低(p<0.001)。rSBP与病变冠状动脉血管数量呈正相关,但与ST段压低程度无关。我们的研究表明,运动后3分钟时的rSBP作为诊断指标不如心肌缺血的经典标准。然而,rSBP具有良好的特异性,尤其是在女性中,从而减少了与ST段压低相关的假阳性检测。rSBP也是冠状动脉疾病严重程度的一个标志物。