Plasschaert A J, Cailleteau J G, Verdonschot E H
Department of Cariology and Endodontology, College of Dental Science, University of Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
Eur J Dent Educ. 1997 May;1(2):66-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0579.1997.tb00014.x.
New technology may create additional opportunities for learning in dental education. One of these new features is a multimedia approach, courseware combining sound, text, stills and video with interactive learning. A multimedia program was developed to train dental students and dental practitioners in decision making and problem solving in endodontics. This study compared the effects of the multimedia program with a more traditional approach consisting of written information, without interaction. 28, 4th-year dental students at the University of Kentucky in Lexington, KY, USA were randomly assigned to the multimedia or the text-based groups. They were given a written pre-test using 2 cases of dental pain and were instructed to study independently using either the multimedia program (group A) or the written information (group B). No restrictions were imposed on the amount of time to be invested, and the total study time was recorded for each student. 3 weeks after the pre-test, the students completed the post-test. A total of 18 students completed both the pre-test and the post-test and their scores were included in the final data. Statistical analysis of the average scores using paired t-tests revealed no significant difference between the performance of the students in either group, indicating that the multimedia approach to learning endodontic problem solving may successfully replace traditional learning strategies.
新技术可能为牙科教育创造更多学习机会。这些新特性之一是多媒体方法,即结合声音、文本、图片和视频并带有交互式学习的课件。开发了一个多媒体程序,用于培训牙科学生和牙科从业者在牙髓病学中的决策和问题解决能力。本研究将多媒体程序的效果与一种更传统的方法(仅包含书面信息且无交互)进行了比较。美国肯塔基州列克星敦市肯塔基大学的28名四年级牙科学生被随机分配到多媒体组或基于文本的组。给他们进行了一次书面预测试,使用2个牙痛病例,并指示他们使用多媒体程序(A组)或书面信息(B组)进行独立学习。对学习投入的时间没有限制,记录了每个学生的总学习时间。预测试3周后,学生们完成了后测试。共有18名学生完成了预测试和后测试,他们的分数被纳入最终数据。使用配对t检验对平均分数进行统计分析,结果显示两组学生的表现没有显著差异,这表明多媒体学习牙髓病问题解决方法可能成功取代传统学习策略。