Langston W, Kramer D C, Glenberg A M
Denison University, Granville, Ohio, USA.
Mem Cognit. 1998 Mar;26(2):247-62. doi: 10.3758/bf03201137.
Mental models of text are representations of what the text is about (i.e., situations), rather than representations of the text itself. Many mental model theories propose that mental models, like real situations, are played out in a medium analogous to a Euclidean space so that distance has functional consequences. For example, when one mentally manipulates one element of the representation, one will notice other elements that are spatially close to it, and this will enhance their short-term accessibility. In a test of this noticing hypothesis, participants read texts that described the object-by-object construction of a spatial layout. According to the text, a critical object ended up close to a target object (in the spatial layout) or far from the target object. In neither case, however, was the relation between the critical object and the target object explicitly described in the text. The noticing hypothesis predicts that the accessibility of the target object will be enhanced when the critical object is close to it. We tested this prediction in seven experiments in which we also manipulated the number of objects described, whether the description was accompanied by a diagram, the presentation modality of the description, the number of dimensions in the spatial layout, and the measurement of accessibility. We failed to find consistent support for the noticing hypothesis. The data compel the conclusions that (1) spatial representations can be formed when one is reading, (2) these representations do not support automatic noticing of implicit spatial relations, (3) it is likely that the spatial representation is more topological or functional than Euclidean.
文本的心理模型是关于文本内容(即情境)的表征,而非文本本身的表征。许多心理模型理论提出,心理模型如同真实情境,在类似于欧几里得空间的媒介中呈现,因此距离具有功能性影响。例如,当人们在心理上操控表征中的一个元素时,会注意到在空间上与之接近的其他元素,这会增强它们在短期内的可及性。在对这一注意假设的一项测试中,参与者阅读描述空间布局逐个物体构建过程的文本。根据文本内容,一个关键物体最终在(空间布局中)靠近或远离一个目标物体。然而,在这两种情况下,文本中都未明确描述关键物体与目标物体之间的关系。注意假设预测,当关键物体靠近目标物体时,目标物体的可及性将会增强。我们在七个实验中对这一预测进行了测试,在这些实验中,我们还操控了所描述物体的数量、描述是否配有图表、描述的呈现方式、空间布局中的维度数量以及可及性的测量方法。我们未能找到对注意假设的一致支持。这些数据迫使我们得出以下结论:(1)阅读时可以形成空间表征;(2)这些表征不支持对隐含空间关系的自动注意;(3)空间表征很可能比欧几里得式的更具拓扑性或功能性。