Rafferty K L
University of Washington, Department of Orthodontics, Seattle 98195-7446, USA.
J Hum Evol. 1998 Apr;34(4):361-83. doi: 10.1006/jhev.1997.0202.
This study investigates the structural design of the femoral neck with respect to phylogeny, locomotor behavior, and body size in a large comparative sample of primates. Since a bone's strength is determined by the amount and arrangement of its constituent material, the amount and distribution of bone in the femoral neck are the focus of the present study. Two types of data were collected. First, the total distribution of bone across the femoral neck (perpendicular to the femoral neck axis) was examined using image analysis techniques. The distribution of both cortical and trabecular bone are included in this analysis. Secondly, the external dimensions of the femoral neck and the thickness of the superior and inferior cortices, measured from radiographs, were used to calculate femoral neck cross-sectional properties (cortical area and second moment of area). These data were input into a simplified cantilevered beam model that incorporates femoral neck-shaft angle and femoral neck length and is used to predict stress under one unit body mass of loading on the femoral head. The patterns of bone distribution in the femoral neck between taxa are broadly similar for the analysis that includes both trabecular and cortical bone and that which includes only cortical bone. In all cases, there tends to be more bone on the inferior aspect of the femoral neck compared to the superior aspect. However, the non-human hominoids and New World monkeys (e.g., Ateles and Alouatta) have a more even distribution of bone across the femoral neck and have thicker superior cortices relative to inferior cortices compared to the rest of the comparative sample, including humans. It is proposed that the more equal distributional pattern in the non-human hominoids and atelines reflects less stereotypical, more generalized loading orientations. Differences between species in overall strength of the femoral neck are a function of both body size and locomotor mode.
本研究在大量灵长类动物的比较样本中,研究了股骨颈在系统发育、运动行为和体型方面的结构设计。由于骨骼的强度取决于其组成材料的数量和排列方式,因此股骨颈中骨骼的数量和分布是本研究的重点。收集了两类数据。首先,使用图像分析技术检查了整个股骨颈(垂直于股骨颈轴线)的骨骼总分布。该分析包括皮质骨和小梁骨的分布。其次,从X光片中测量股骨颈的外部尺寸以及上下皮质的厚度,用于计算股骨颈的横截面特性(皮质面积和面积惯性矩)。这些数据被输入到一个简化的悬臂梁模型中,该模型纳入了股骨颈-骨干角度和股骨颈长度,并用于预测在股骨头承受一个单位体重负荷时的应力。对于包括小梁骨和皮质骨的分析以及仅包括皮质骨的分析,不同分类单元之间股骨颈的骨分布模式大致相似。在所有情况下,与上侧相比,股骨颈下侧的骨骼往往更多。然而,与包括人类在内的其他比较样本相比,非人类类人猿和新大陆猴(如蛛猴和吼猴)在股骨颈上的骨骼分布更为均匀,且上皮质相对于下皮质更厚。有人提出,非人类类人猿和蛛猴科动物中更均匀的分布模式反映了较少刻板、更普遍的负荷方向。股骨颈整体强度在物种间的差异是体型和运动方式共同作用的结果。