Bingefors K, Isacson D G
Department of Psychiatry, University Hospital, Uppsala, Sweden.
Ann Pharmacother. 1998 May;32(5):531-5. doi: 10.1345/aph.17211.
To evaluate concomitant prescribing of tranquilizers and hypnotics in antidepressant treatment with particular focus on the relationship to drug class in patients prescribed antidepressant treatment for depressive disorders.
Repeated cross-sectional surveys of Swedish physicians in ambulatory care from 1991 to 1996, including specialty practices. The participation rate was 65-70%.
Tranquilizers and hypnotics were prescribed in 36.1% of the visits in which the intention was to treat depression. Concomitant prescribing increased with the patient's age for all antidepressant drug classes. Women received more concomitant prescriptions than men when treated with nonselective monoamine-reuptake inhibitors (NSMRI), mainly tricyclic compounds. Psychiatrists prescribed more concomitant tranquilizers and hypnotics than other physicians, and general practitioners fewer, when treating depression with selective serotonin-reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs), mainly citalopram. A logistic regression model showed that the risk for concomitant prescribing was higher when an NSMRI was prescribed than with other antidepressants.
Concomitant prescribing of tranquilizers and hypnotics was common among antidepressant-treated patients. The most plausible reasons for the high rate of concomitant prescribing were the symptoms of the depression itself and/or the common comorbidity with anxiety disorders seen in this group of patients. The results of this study indicate that the concern about increased tranquilizer and hypnotic use among patients treated with SSRIs suggested in other studies seems to be unfounded in Sweden.
评估在抑郁症患者的抗抑郁治疗中同时开具镇静剂和催眠药的情况,特别关注与所开具抗抑郁药物种类的关系。
对1991年至1996年瑞典门诊医疗中的医生进行重复横断面调查,包括专科诊疗。参与率为65%-70%。
在旨在治疗抑郁症的就诊中,36.1%的患者开具了镇静剂和催眠药。所有抗抑郁药物种类的同时用药率均随患者年龄增加而上升。使用非选择性单胺再摄取抑制剂(NSMRI,主要是三环类化合物)治疗时,女性比男性接受的同时用药处方更多。在用选择性5-羟色胺再摄取抑制剂(SSRI,主要是西酞普兰)治疗抑郁症时,精神科医生开具的同时使用的镇静剂和催眠药比其他医生多,全科医生开具的则较少。逻辑回归模型显示,开具NSMRI时同时用药的风险高于使用其他抗抑郁药时。
在接受抗抑郁治疗的患者中,同时开具镇静剂和催眠药的情况很常见。同时用药率高最合理的原因是抑郁症本身的症状和/或该组患者中常见的焦虑症共病。本研究结果表明,其他研究中提到的对使用SSRI治疗的患者增加使用镇静剂和催眠药的担忧在瑞典似乎没有依据。