Pollock B E, Flickinger J C, Lunsford L D, Maitz A, Kondziolka D
Department of Neurological Surgery, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota 55905, USA.
Neurosurgery. 1998 Jun;42(6):1239-44; discussion 1244-7. doi: 10.1097/00006123-199806000-00020.
To analyze the clinical and angiographic variables that affect the results of arteriovenous malformation (AVM) radiosurgery and to propose a new method of reporting patient outcomes after AVM radiosurgery. This method incorporates both the obliteration status of the AVMs and the postoperative neurological condition of the patient.
Patient outcomes were defined as excellent (nidus obliteration and no new deficits), good (nidus obliteration with a new minor deficit), fair (nidus obliteration with a new major deficit), unchanged (incomplete nidus obliteration without a new deficit), poor (incomplete nidus obliteration with any new deficit), and dead. Two hundred twenty patients who underwent AVM radiosurgery at our center before 1992 were subjected to a multivariate analysis with patient outcomes as the dependent variable.
Multivariate analysis determined four factors associated with successful AVM radiosurgery: smaller AVM volume (P=0.003), number of draining veins (P=0.001), younger patient age (P=0.0003), and hemispheric AVM location (P=0.002). Preradiosurgical embolization was a negative predictor of successful AVM radiosurgery (P=0.02).
AVM obliteration without new neurological deficits can be achieved in at least 80% of patients with small volume, hemispheric AVMs after single-session AVM radiosurgery. Future studies on AVM radiosurgery should report patient outcomes in a fashion that incorporates all the factors involved in successful AVM radiosurgery.
分析影响动静脉畸形(AVM)放射外科治疗效果的临床和血管造影变量,并提出一种报告AVM放射外科治疗后患者预后的新方法。该方法纳入了AVM的闭塞状态和患者术后的神经状况。
将患者预后定义为优(畸形灶闭塞且无新的神经功能缺损)、良(畸形灶闭塞但有新的轻度神经功能缺损)、中(畸形灶闭塞但有新的重度神经功能缺损)、不变(畸形灶未完全闭塞且无新的神经功能缺损)、差(畸形灶未完全闭塞且有任何新的神经功能缺损)及死亡。对1992年前在本中心接受AVM放射外科治疗的220例患者进行多因素分析,以患者预后作为因变量。
多因素分析确定了与AVM放射外科治疗成功相关的四个因素:较小的AVM体积(P = 0.003)、引流静脉数量(P = 0.001)、患者年龄较轻(P = 0.0003)以及半球型AVM位置(P = 0.002)。放射外科治疗前的栓塞是AVM放射外科治疗成功的负性预测因素(P = 0.02)。
对于体积较小的半球型AVM患者,单次AVM放射外科治疗后至少80%可实现AVM闭塞且无新的神经功能缺损。未来关于AVM放射外科治疗的研究应以纳入AVM放射外科治疗成功所涉及的所有因素的方式报告患者预后。