Meusers P, Brittinger G
Abteilung für Hämatologie, Universitätsklinikum-Gesamthochschule, Essen.
Praxis (Bern 1994). 1998 Jun 3;87(23):793-800.
In 1994 the International Lymphoma Study Group (ILSG) published the "Revised European-American Classification of Lymphoid Neoplasms" (R.E.A.L. Classification). Lymphomas were classified according to their presumed normal counterparts, to the extent possible. Within both T- and B-cell categories differentiation between lymphomas and/or leukemias of "precursor" or "peripheral" neoplasms are defined arising from antigen independend or antigen reactive cell proliferation. Lymphomas undoubtedly characterized by currently available morphologic, immunologic, and genetic technics represent "real" disease entities. Provisional categories include lymphomas that have been described in some detail, but without consensus within the ILSG. Proposed names are based predominantly on established usage. With respect to similar treatment approaches and difficulties of the ILSG members in subclassifying large cell lymphomas, centroblastic, immunoblastic and large cell anaplastic lymphomas of B-cell type were "lumped" together as large B-cell lymphomas. Within a prospective treatment trial overall survival was significantly better in centroblastic as compared to B-cell immunoblastic lymphoma diagnosed by optimal histomorphology according the criteria of the Kiel Classification. Thus the R.E.A.L. Classification fails to identify patients who may require other than standard treatment. Future studies will demonstrate whether subclassifying the proposed "peripheral" T-cell lymphomas, unspecified into T-zone lymphoma, lymphoepitheloid (Lennert's) lymphoma and pleomorphic, small, medium, and large cell lymphomas according the Kiel Classification is of clinicopathologic relevance. On the contrary the subtypes of chronic lymphocytic leukemia of T-cell type form two distinct entities within the R.E.A.L. Classification separating T-CLL/prolymphocytic leukemia from large granular lymphocyte leukemia of T- and NK-cell type. Within the R.E.A.L. Classification the lymphoplasmacytoid immunocytoma of the Kiel Classification will be subsumed together with the prognostically significantly better B-cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia. Opposite to the original intention of the ILSG two proposals are developed on clinical grouping of entities. Clinical indolent lymphoid neoplasms usually have "low grade" histologic appearances, with a predominance of small cells subsuming with the exception of the mantle cell lymphoma all of the low grade lymphomas of the Kiel classification. Aggressive lymphomas (intermediate risk) are defined as tumors whose survival if untreated is measured in months, highly or very aggressive lymphomas and/or leukemias will kill untreated patients within weeks. Unlike the Kiel Classification proposed categories subsume lymphomas irrespective of cytomorphology, thus grouping together potentially curable and uncurable diseases. Undoubtedly the R.E.A.L. Classification forms at present the best compilation of existing knowledge upon neoplasms of the immune system, enabling cooperation between clinicians and scientists all over the world. According to the ILSG this proposal should be considered a starting point for future periodic reevaluations.
1994年,国际淋巴瘤研究组(ILSG)发表了《欧美淋巴样肿瘤修订分类》(R.E.A.L.分类)。淋巴瘤尽可能根据其假定的正常对应物进行分类。在T细胞和B细胞类别中,淋巴瘤和/或白血病的“前体”或“外周”肿瘤之间的区别是根据抗原非依赖性或抗原反应性细胞增殖来定义的。无疑,目前可用的形态学、免疫学和遗传学技术所表征的淋巴瘤代表了“真正的”疾病实体。临时类别包括一些已被详细描述但ILSG内部未达成共识的淋巴瘤。提议的名称主要基于既定用法。关于ILSG成员在对大细胞淋巴瘤进行亚分类时遇到的类似治疗方法和困难,B细胞型中心母细胞性、免疫母细胞性和大细胞间变性淋巴瘤被“归为”大B细胞淋巴瘤。在一项前瞻性治疗试验中,根据基尔分类标准通过最佳组织形态学诊断的中心母细胞性淋巴瘤与B细胞免疫母细胞性淋巴瘤相比,总生存率显著更高。因此,R.E.A.L.分类未能识别出可能需要标准治疗以外其他治疗的患者。未来的研究将证明,根据基尔分类将提议的“外周”T细胞淋巴瘤(未指定)进一步细分为T区淋巴瘤、淋巴上皮样( Lennert's)淋巴瘤以及多形性、小、中、大细胞淋巴瘤是否具有临床病理相关性。相反,T细胞型慢性淋巴细胞白血病的亚型在R.E.A.L.分类中形成了两个不同的实体,将T-CLL/原淋巴细胞白血病与T细胞和NK细胞型大颗粒淋巴细胞白血病区分开来。在R.E.A.L.分类中,基尔分类中的淋巴浆细胞样免疫细胞瘤将与预后明显较好的B细胞慢性淋巴细胞白血病归为一类。与ILSG的初衷相反,针对实体的临床分组提出了两项建议。临床惰性淋巴样肿瘤通常具有“低级别”组织学表现,以小细胞为主,除套细胞淋巴瘤外,涵盖了基尔分类中的所有低级别淋巴瘤。侵袭性淋巴瘤(中度风险)被定义为未经治疗其生存期以月计算的肿瘤,高度或极高度侵袭性淋巴瘤和/或白血病将在数周内导致未经治疗的患者死亡。与基尔分类不同,提议的类别不论细胞形态如何对淋巴瘤进行归类,从而将潜在可治愈和不可治愈的疾病归在一起。无疑,R.E.A.L.分类目前构成了关于免疫系统肿瘤现有知识的最佳汇编,使世界各地的临床医生和科学家能够开展合作。根据ILSG的说法,该提议应被视为未来定期重新评估的起点。