Lund E, Gram I T
Institute of Community Medicine, University of Tromso, Norway.
Scand J Soc Med. 1998 Jun;26(2):154-60. doi: 10.1177/14034948980260020401.
The purpose of this study was to investigate how response rates to a postal questionnaire are affected by title and length of the survey instrument. Five questionnaires, which differed according to title and length, were designed. Each questionnaire was mailed to a random sample of one thousand Norwegian women aged, 35-49 years. A total of 3,106 questionnaires were returned (62.1%). The highest response rate (70.2%) was achieved by a two-page questionnaire entitled "Women and Cancer". An otherwise identical questionnaire entitled "Oral Contraceptives and Cancer" had a response rate of 60.7%. Questionnaires entitled "Women and Cancer" with a length of four and six pages had a response rate of 62.8% and 63.3%, respectively. The four page questionnaire entitled "Women, Lifestyle and Health" had the lowest response rate of 57.1%. This study shows that in a general population of Norwegian women the title of a postal questionnaire influences the response rate. The results indicate that although the shortest questionnaire had the highest response rate, the most extensive survey instrument did not have the lowest response rate. The distribution of risk factors for breast cancer did not vary according to response rate or design of questionnaire. The overall findings of this study suggest that the benefits from the increased information obtained from extensive postal questionnaires out-weighs a potential non-response bias due to a somewhat lower response rate.
本研究的目的是调查邮寄调查问卷的回复率如何受到调查工具的标题和长度的影响。设计了五份根据标题和长度不同的问卷。每份问卷都邮寄给了1000名年龄在35至49岁之间的挪威女性的随机样本。总共收到了3106份问卷回复(回复率为62.1%)。一份名为《女性与癌症》的两页问卷获得了最高回复率(70.2%)。另一份标题为《口服避孕药与癌症》的内容完全相同的问卷,回复率为60.7%。标题为《女性与癌症》的四页和六页问卷的回复率分别为62.8%和63.3%。标题为《女性、生活方式与健康》的四页问卷回复率最低,为57.1%。这项研究表明,在挪威女性的总体人群中,邮寄调查问卷的标题会影响回复率。结果表明,虽然最短的问卷回复率最高,但内容最详尽的调查工具回复率并非最低。乳腺癌风险因素的分布并未因回复率或问卷设计而有所不同。本研究的总体结果表明,从详尽的邮寄调查问卷中获得的更多信息所带来的益处,超过了因回复率略低而可能产生的无回应偏差。