Thiels C, Schmidt U, Treasure J, Garthe R, Troop N
Bielefeld Polytechnic, Germany.
Am J Psychiatry. 1998 Jul;155(7):947-53. doi: 10.1176/ajp.155.7.947.
The aim of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of guided self-change for bulimia nervosa.
Sixty-two patients with DSM-III-R-defined bulimia nervosa were randomly assigned to 1) use of a self-care manual plus eight fortnightly sessions of cognitive behavior therapy (guided self-change) or 2) 16 sessions of weekly cognitive behavior therapy.
At the end of treatment and at follow-up an average of 43 weeks after the end of therapy, substantial improvements had been achieved in both groups on the main outcome measures: eating disorder symptoms according to experts' ratings (Eating Disorder Examination subscores on overeating, vomiting, dietary restraint, and shape and weight concerns), self-reports (Bulimic Investigatory Test Edinburgh), and a 5-point severity scale. Also, improvement was seen on the subsidiary outcome measures: the Beck Depression Inventory, the Self-Concept Questionnaire, and knowledge of nutrition, weight, and shape. At follow-up, 71% of the cognitive behavior therapy group had not binged or vomited during the week preceding. In the guided self-change group, 70% had not binged and 61% had not vomited during the week before follow-up.
Guided self-change incorporating use of a self-care manual offers an approach that can be as effective as standard cognitive behavior therapy in the long term and can considerably reduce the amount of therapist contact required.
本研究旨在评估引导式自我改变对神经性贪食症的有效性。
62名符合DSM-III-R标准的神经性贪食症患者被随机分为两组:1)使用自我护理手册并接受为期8个双周的认知行为疗法(引导式自我改变);2)接受为期16周的每周一次的认知行为疗法。
在治疗结束时以及治疗结束后平均43周的随访中,两组在主要结局指标上均取得了显著改善:根据专家评分的饮食失调症状(饮食失调检查中关于暴饮暴食、呕吐、饮食限制以及对体型和体重关注的子评分)、自我报告(爱丁堡贪食症调查测试)以及一个5分严重程度量表。此外,在次要结局指标上也有改善:贝克抑郁量表、自我概念问卷以及营养、体重和体型知识。随访时,认知行为疗法组71%的患者在随访前一周内未出现暴饮暴食或呕吐。在引导式自我改变组中,70%的患者在随访前一周内未出现暴饮暴食,61%的患者未出现呕吐。
结合使用自我护理手册的引导式自我改变提供了一种方法,从长期来看,其效果与标准认知行为疗法相当,并且可以大幅减少所需的治疗师接触次数。