Aguiar A, Baillargeon R
Department of Psychology, University of Illinois, Champaign 61820, USA.
Child Dev. 1998 Jun;69(3):636-53.
The present research examined whether 8.5-month-old infants take into account the width and compressibility of an object when determining whether it can be inserted into a container. The infants in Experiment 1 saw 2 test events. At the start of each event, a tall container rested on the apparatus floor. Next, the container was hidden by a screen, and a large ball attached to the lower end of a rod was introduced into the apparatus and lowered behind the screen into the container. Finally, the screen was removed to reveal the ball's rod protruding above the container's rim. The only difference between the 2 test events had to do with the width of the containers: in 1 event (large-container event), the container was slightly wider than the ball; in the other event (small-container event), the container was only half as wide as the ball, so that it should have been impossible for the ball to be lowered into it. Infants in a control condition saw identical test events except that a small ball was used that could fit into either the large or the small container. The infants in the experimental condition looked reliably longer at the small- than at the large-container event, whereas those in the control condition tended to look equally at the 2 events. These results suggested that, although the infants never saw the ball and the container simultaneously, they realized that the large ball could fit into the large but not the small container, whereas the small ball could fit into both containers. In Experiment 2, the large ball used in Experiment 1 was replaced with an equally large but compressible ball. The results were negative, suggesting that the infants understood that the large compressible ball could be inserted into either the small or the large container. Finally, Experiment 3 confirmed the results of the experimental condition in Experiment 1, with a slightly different procedure. Together, the present results indicate that, by 8.5 months of age, infants are already capable of sophisticated reasoning about containment events.
本研究考察了8.5个月大的婴儿在判断一个物体是否能被放入容器时,是否会考虑物体的宽度和可压缩性。实验1中的婴儿观看了两个测试事件。在每个事件开始时,一个高容器放置在仪器地板上。接下来,容器被一块屏幕遮住,一个连接在杆下端的大球被引入仪器并降到屏幕后面的容器中。最后,屏幕被移除,露出球的杆伸出容器边缘之上。这两个测试事件之间唯一的区别与容器的宽度有关:在一个事件(大容器事件)中,容器比球略宽;在另一个事件(小容器事件)中,容器的宽度只有球的一半,所以球不可能被放进去。处于对照条件的婴儿观看了相同的测试事件,只是使用了一个能放入大容器或小容器的小球。处于实验条件的婴儿对小容器事件的注视时间明显长于大容器事件,而处于对照条件的婴儿对这两个事件的注视时间倾向于相同。这些结果表明,尽管婴儿从未同时看到球和容器,但他们意识到大球能放进大容器而不能放进小容器,而小球能放进两个容器。在实验2中,实验1中使用的大球被换成了一个同样大但可压缩的球。结果是否定的,这表明婴儿理解大的可压缩球可以放入小容器或大容器中。最后,实验3用稍有不同的程序证实了实验1中实验条件的结果。总体而言,目前的结果表明,到8.5个月大时,婴儿已经能够对容纳事件进行复杂的推理。