Wittig J R, Dunkelberg H, Pfeiffer E H, Werner H P
Zentralbl Bakteriol Orig B. 1976 Mar;161(5-6):408-16.
As part of an investigation carried out in 50 hospitals we particularly checked the sterilisers available for proper functioning and correct operation. The work group examined 461 sterilisation programmes in 338 sterilisation units (176 autoclaves, 153 hot-air apparatus and 9 ethylene oxide units) during the daily routine operation. The group carried out biological and physical inspections and carefully recorded the faults and deficiencies detected during the sterilisation procedure. It was found that only in 22% of the hospitals was a proper functioning and correct operation of all the sterilising units in use ensured. Technical faults and errors in operating the equipment and especially in the loading in 23% of the programmes prevented sterility. Almost 50% of the hot-air sterilisers and about a quarter of the autoclaves fail to produce a consistent satisfactory effect. The incidence of errors which occurred with ethylene oxide sterilisation cannot be generalised, since only a limited number of units were checked. A breakdown by functional areas and wards indicates that serious errors occur not only in the centralised large units but also in little-used small autoclaves in peripheral areas. A comparison with the literature shows that our results do not differ to any appreciable extent from those obtained by other workers, over the last twenty years. Here systematic inspections by external control authorities could improve the situation within a few years. Regular inspections to be carried out by the hospitals themselves using modern test methods are necessary, and need internal record-keeping. In spite of this, we cannot at present do without external inspections. We pin our hopes mainly in regular and thorough expert training of the staff and on much closer cooperation between hospital and hygienist.
作为在50家医院开展的一项调查的一部分,我们专门检查了现有消毒器的正常运行情况和正确操作方法。工作小组在日常运行期间,对338个消毒单元(176个高压灭菌器、153个热风设备和9个环氧乙烷装置)中的461个消毒程序进行了检查。该小组进行了生物学和物理检查,并仔细记录了消毒过程中发现的故障和缺陷。结果发现,只有22%的医院能确保所有在用消毒单元正常运行且操作正确。23%的程序中,设备操作方面的技术故障和错误,尤其是装载问题,导致了消毒失败。近50%的热风消毒器和约四分之一的高压灭菌器无法始终产生令人满意的效果。环氧乙烷消毒出现错误的发生率无法一概而论,因为仅检查了有限数量的装置。按功能区域和病房分类的故障情况表明,严重错误不仅发生在集中式大型装置中,也发生在周边地区很少使用的小型高压灭菌器中。与文献对比表明,在过去二十年里,我们的结果与其他研究人员的结果没有明显差异。外部监管机构进行系统检查,有望在几年内改善这种状况。医院自身有必要使用现代检测方法定期进行检查,并做好内部记录。尽管如此,目前我们仍离不开外部检查。我们主要寄希望于对工作人员进行定期且全面的专业培训,以及医院与卫生学家之间更紧密的合作。