Crawford P
Department of Neurosciences, York District Hospital, UK.
Seizure. 1998 Jun;7(3):207-11. doi: 10.1016/s1059-1311(98)80037-x.
The purpose of this study was to look at the efficacy and side effect profile of topiramate in a neurology unit. Using case notes, 94 patients who had been treated with topiramate were identified: 48 patients had taken part in clinical trials of topiramate, 46 received topiramate once licensed. Of these patients 24% had a greater than 50% decrease in seizure frequency. Patients with primary generalized epilepsy (n = 12) had a greater reduction in seizures compared with those with partial epilepsies (n = 70) P > 0.03. There was a high incidence (41%) of side effects, particularly psychiatric problems, leading to withdrawal of therpay in 41% of patients. Seven patients were admitted to hospital as a result of psychotic symptoms or depression. The incidence of psychotic symptoms (12%) was significantly higher for patients receiving topiramate compared with 191 patients attending the department on gabapentin (0.5%) and 270 patients attending the department on lamotrigine (0.7%) P < 0.001. 'Abnormal thinking', consisting of mental slowing and word-finding difficulties, occurred in 31%. The incidence could be significantly reduced by using 25 mg dose increments fortnightly as opposed to 100 mg weekly (P > 0.03). Although topiramate is an effective antiepileptic drug, its use is accompanied by a high incidence of particularly psychiatric side effects.
本研究的目的是观察托吡酯在神经内科病房的疗效和副作用情况。通过病历记录,确定了94例接受托吡酯治疗的患者:48例患者参与了托吡酯的临床试验,46例在该药获批上市后接受了治疗。这些患者中,24%的癫痫发作频率降低了50%以上。与部分性癫痫患者(n = 70)相比,原发性全身性癫痫患者(n = 12)的癫痫发作减少更为明显(P > 0.03)。副作用发生率较高(41%),尤其是精神方面的问题,导致41%的患者停药。7例患者因精神症状或抑郁入院。接受托吡酯治疗的患者精神症状发生率(12%)显著高于在该科室接受加巴喷丁治疗的191例患者(0.5%)以及接受拉莫三嗪治疗的270例患者(0.7%)(P < 0.001)。31%的患者出现了包括思维迟缓及找词困难在内的“思维异常”。与每周增加100 mg剂量相比,每两周增加25 mg剂量可显著降低该发生率(P > 0.03)。尽管托吡酯是一种有效的抗癫痫药物,但其使用伴随着较高的副作用发生率,尤其是精神方面的副作用。