Stoddard J J, Brotherton S E, Tang S F
Kids First Hockessin, Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, Del, USA.
Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 1998 Aug;152(8):768-73. doi: 10.1001/archpedi.152.8.768.
To assess the respective roles of general pediatricians and pediatric subspecialists in the provision of primary pediatric care.
A practice characteristics questionnaire that included questions about primary care was sent to a random sample of 1616 board-certified and board-eligible active Fellows of the American Academy of Pediatrics; 1145 (70.9%) responded. Analyses pertain to those pediatricians who provided ambulatory patient care and were not in graduate medical education training at the time of the survey. Respondents were divided into 2 groups for purposes of analysis: the 527 pediatricians whose practice was primarily in general pediatrics (defined as 80% of time spent in general pediatrics or any time spent in adolescent medicine) and the 213 pediatricians whose practice was subspecialty focused (all others). These groups were then further stratified according to whether they provided primary care. The resultant subgroups contained 518 general pediatricians and 98 subspecialists who provided primary care.
Among the entire sample, general pediatricians indicated that general pediatricians provide 93% of the primary care delivered by their practice and that pediatric subspecialists provide 2% of the primary care. In contrast, pediatric subspecialists reported that general pediatricians provide 53% of the primary care delivered by their practice and that subspecialists provide 32% of such care (P<.001). Among the subsample of pediatricians who provide primary care, general pediatricians reported delivering 88% of the primary care received by their patients and subspecialists reported delivering 74% of the primary care received by their patients (P<.001).
Perspectives on the degree to which pediatric subspecialists provide primary pediatric care vary depending on generalist vs subspecialist self-identification.
评估普通儿科医生和儿科专科医生在提供初级儿科护理方面各自的作用。
向1616名美国儿科学会认证合格及符合认证资格的在职会员随机抽样发送一份包含初级护理相关问题的执业特征调查问卷;1145人(70.9%)回复。分析针对那些提供门诊患者护理且在调查时未接受研究生医学教育培训的儿科医生。为便于分析,将受访者分为两组:527名主要从事普通儿科的儿科医生(定义为80%的时间用于普通儿科或任何时间用于青少年医学)和213名专注于专科的儿科医生(其他所有人)。然后根据他们是否提供初级护理对这些组进一步分层。最终的亚组包括518名提供初级护理的普通儿科医生和98名提供初级护理的专科医生。
在整个样本中,普通儿科医生表示普通儿科医生提供其执业中93%的初级护理,儿科专科医生提供2%的初级护理。相比之下,儿科专科医生报告普通儿科医生提供其执业中53%的初级护理,专科医生提供32%的此类护理(P<0.001)。在提供初级护理的儿科医生子样本中,普通儿科医生报告提供其患者接受的88%的初级护理,专科医生报告提供其患者接受的74%的初级护理(P<0.001)。
对于儿科专科医生提供初级儿科护理的程度的看法因通科医生与专科医生的自我认知不同而有所差异。