Benjamin L S
Am J Psychiatry. 1976 Oct;133(10):1129-33. doi: 10.1176/ajp.133.10.1129.
The author reviews a study by Kety and associates that reported a significantly greater prevalence of schizophrenic spectrum disorders among the biological relatives of schizophrenic adoptees than among those of nonschizophrenic adoptees. The principal statistical analysis of the Kety study used an incorrect sample size (306 rather than 66) and failed to weight each index and control case (family) equally. This violation of the independence assumption would allow a few families to disproportionately influence the outcome. The author argues that proper statistical analysis applied separately to available categories indicates that significant differences between the index and control groups occurred mainly in the half-sibling category; this result violates the principle that genetic effects increase with greater consanguinity. She concludes that Kety and associates' study raises more questions than it answers regarding the role of genetic factors in schizophrenia.
作者回顾了凯蒂及其同事的一项研究,该研究报告称,精神分裂症被收养者的生物学亲属中精神分裂症谱系障碍的患病率显著高于非精神分裂症被收养者的生物学亲属。凯蒂研究的主要统计分析使用了错误的样本量(306而非66),并且没有对每个索引病例和对照病例(家庭)进行同等加权。这种对独立性假设的违反会使少数家庭对结果产生不成比例的影响。作者认为,对可用类别分别进行适当的统计分析表明,索引组和对照组之间的显著差异主要出现在同父异母或同母异父兄弟姐妹类别中;这一结果违反了遗传效应随血缘关系增加而增强的原则。她得出结论,关于遗传因素在精神分裂症中的作用,凯蒂及其同事的研究提出的问题比给出的答案更多。