Callister T Q, Cooil B, Raya S P, Lippolis N J, Russo D J, Raggi P
EBT Research Foundation, Hendersonville, TN 37075, USA.
Radiology. 1998 Sep;208(3):807-14. doi: 10.1148/radiology.208.3.9722864.
To assess the variability and reproducibility of a volumetric calcium score calculated with electron-bean computed tomographic (CT) scans of coronary arteries.
Two sets of electron-beam CT scans were obtained in patients with coronary calcification (group A) or known risk factors for coronary arterial disease (group B). The second set or scans was obtained after a brief interval (group A, n = 52) or after 1 year with no risk modification (group B, n = 27). Traditional (plaque area and attenuation) and volumetric calcium scores were calculated for each patient and lesion.
The median percentage change for individual lesions in group A was 13% for the volumetric and 19% for the traditional score. The overall reduction in error with the volumetric score was 40% (P < .001). The median percentage change for group A patient totals was 9% for the volumetric and 15% for the traditional score (P < .001). In group B patients, the median volumetric score increased by 44% after 1 year.
The volumetric score showed better reproducibility than the traditional score, and its variability was considerably less than the score increase in untreated patients after 1 year. The reproducibility of the volumetric method makes it useful for assessing the progression of coronary arterial disease on serial electron-beam CT studies.
评估通过冠状动脉电子束计算机断层扫描(CT)计算的容积性钙评分的变异性和可重复性。
对患有冠状动脉钙化的患者(A组)或已知有冠状动脉疾病危险因素的患者(B组)进行两组电子束CT扫描。第二组扫描在短暂间隔后(A组,n = 52)或1年后在无风险因素改变的情况下进行(B组,n = 27)。为每位患者和病变计算传统(斑块面积和衰减)和容积性钙评分。
A组单个病变的容积性评分中位数百分比变化为13%,传统评分的中位数百分比变化为19%。容积性评分的总体误差降低了40%(P <.001)。A组患者总体的容积性评分中位数百分比变化为9%,传统评分的中位数百分比变化为15%(P <.001)。在B组患者中,1年后容积性评分中位数增加了44%。
容积性评分比传统评分显示出更好的可重复性,并且其变异性明显小于未经治疗患者1年后评分的增加。容积性方法的可重复性使其在连续电子束CT研究中对评估冠状动脉疾病的进展有用。