Zabinski S J, Sculco T P, Dicarlo E F, Rivelis M
The Hospital for Special Surgery, New York, New York 10021, USA.
J Rheumatol. 1998 Sep;25(9):1674-80.
To define the prevalence and pathological spectrum of femoral head osteonecrosis in patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and to correlate its presence with disease related clinical and therapeutic factors.
A total of 545 primary total hip arthroplasties performed in 507 patients with RA were identified. A historical review of each patient's rheumatoid disease and treatment as well as pathological review of each femoral head specimen was performed.
Osteonecrosis was identified in 66 specimens (12.1%) in one of 2 discrete forms. Thirty-two specimens (5.9%) contained classic subchondral avascular necrosis. Thirty-four specimens (6.2%) contained osteonecrosis in association with degenerative changes (within regions of sclerotic and eburnated subchondral bone), but not classic avascular necrosis. Remaining femoral head specimens were characterized by inflammatory arthritis (431 specimens) or degenerative joint disease (48 specimens). Corticosteroid therapy was used in 81% of patients with avascular necrosis and 68% with degenerative osteonecrosis. This was significantly greater prevalence than in patients without osteonecrosis (33%). Average daily prednisone dosage was 8 mg and no association between dosage and the presence of osteonecrosis was identified. No correlation between pathological findings and clinical disease severity was identified. In 5 of 27 specimens showing classic avascular necrosis and 11 of 34 containing degenerative osteonecrosis, no steroid treatment had been administered.
Femoral head osteonecrosis is present in about 12% of patients with RA at hip arthroplasty, and occurs in 2 forms -- classic avascular necrosis and degenerative necrosis. Both forms are significantly associated with corticosteroid use. "Low dose" therapy does not protect patients against the development of osteonecrosis. Additionally, baseline prevalence of osteonecrosis of about 3% occurs in the absence of steroid use and may be related to the underlying inflammatory diseases. Despite its association with osteonecrosis the net effect of corticosteroid therapy on the natural history of rheumatoid hip disease remains unclear.
明确类风湿关节炎(RA)患者股骨头坏死的患病率及病理谱,并将其存在情况与疾病相关的临床和治疗因素相关联。
确定了507例RA患者接受的545例初次全髋关节置换术。对每位患者的类风湿疾病和治疗进行了历史回顾,并对每个股骨头标本进行了病理检查。
在66个标本(12.1%)中发现了2种不同形式之一的坏死。32个标本(5.9%)含有典型的软骨下缺血性坏死。34个标本(6.2%)含有与退行性改变相关的坏死(在硬化和骨化的软骨下骨区域内),但不是典型的缺血性坏死。其余股骨头标本的特征为炎性关节炎(431个标本)或退行性关节病(48个标本)。81%的缺血性坏死患者和68%的退行性坏死患者使用了皮质类固醇治疗。这一患病率明显高于无坏死患者(33%)。泼尼松的平均每日剂量为8毫克,未发现剂量与坏死存在之间的关联。未发现病理结果与临床疾病严重程度之间的相关性。在27个显示典型缺血性坏死的标本中有5个以及34个含有退行性坏死的标本中有11个未接受类固醇治疗。
在接受髋关节置换术的RA患者中,约12%存在股骨头坏死,且以2种形式出现——典型的缺血性坏死和退行性坏死。两种形式均与皮质类固醇的使用显著相关。“低剂量”治疗不能保护患者免于发生坏死。此外,在未使用类固醇的情况下,坏死的基线患病率约为3%,这可能与潜在的炎症性疾病有关。尽管皮质类固醇治疗与坏死有关,但其对类风湿性髋关节疾病自然史的净效应仍不清楚。