Coulter I, Adams A, Coggan P, Wilkes M, Gonyea M
School of Dentistry, University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), USA.
Altern Ther Health Med. 1998 Sep;4(5):64-75.
Chiropractic is the largest of the alternative/complementary health professions in North America. However, little attention has been given in the health sciences literature to the formal curriculum of chiropractic education or to its similarities to and differences from the curriculum of allopathic medical education. This lack of information precludes extensive referrals and interaction between the 2 professions, even when historical and political barriers can be overcome.
This is a descriptive, comparative study of the curriculum content of North American chiropractic and medical colleges, supplemented by in-depth data obtained through site visits with 6 institutions (3 chiropractic and 3 medical).
Considerable commonality exists between chiropractic and medical programs. Regarding the basic sciences, these programs are more similar than dissimilar, both in the types of subjects offered and in the time allotted to each subject. The programs also share some common areas in the clinical sciences. Chiropractic and allopathic medicine differ the greatest in clinical practice, which in medical school far exceeds that in chiropractic school. The therapies that chiropractic and medical students learn are distinct from one another, and the settings in which students receive clinical training are different and isolated from one another. With these similarities and differences established, future studies should examine the quality of the 2 educational programs in detail.
整脊疗法是北美最大的替代/补充健康专业。然而,健康科学文献中很少关注整脊疗法教育的正规课程,或其与对抗疗法医学教育课程的异同。这种信息匮乏阻碍了这两个专业之间的广泛转诊和互动,即使历史和政治障碍能够克服。
这是一项对北美整脊疗法学院和医学院课程内容的描述性比较研究,并通过对6所机构(3所整脊疗法学院和3所医学院)的实地考察获得的深入数据进行补充。
整脊疗法和医学课程之间存在相当多的共性。在基础科学方面,这些课程在提供的学科类型和分配给每个学科的时间上,相似之处多于不同之处。这些课程在临床科学方面也有一些共同领域。整脊疗法和对抗疗法在临床实践方面差异最大,医学院的临床实践远远超过整脊疗法学院。整脊疗法和医学专业学生所学的疗法各不相同,学生接受临床培训的环境也不同且相互隔离。明确了这些异同之后,未来的研究应详细考察这两种教育课程的质量。