Phillips K, Bentley M C, Howard D A, Alván G
Department of Air Quality Monitoring, Covance Laboratories Ltd., Harrogate, North Yorkshire, England.
Int Arch Occup Environ Health. 1998 Sep;71(6):379-90. doi: 10.1007/s004200050296.
Exposures to respirable suspended particles (RSP) and environmental tobacco smoke (ETS) were assessed in Prague, Czech Republic, to determine the range and degree of personal exposure by means of personal monitoring over a 24-h period.
Self-reported nonsmokers were randomly selected from a representative sample of the population of Prague. Housewives were recruited into one group, primarily for assessment exposures in the home, and office workers were recruited into a second group for assessment of the contribution from the workplace.
A total of 238 randomly selected nonsmoking subjects collected air samples near their breathing zone by wearing personal monitors for 24 h. Samples collected were analyzed for RSP, nicotine, 3-ethenylpyridine, and ETS particles (using ultraviolet absorbance, fluorescence, and solanesol measurements). Saliva cotinine analyses were also undertaken to confirm the nonsmoking status of the subjects.
The most highly exposed subjects in this study were office workers both living and working with smokers. Median time-weighted average exposure concentrations of 60 microg m(-3)RSP, 16 microg m(-3)ETS particles, and 1.6 microg m(-3) nicotine were determined for these subjects, who also had the highest median saliva cotinine level of 2.4 ng ml(-1). Housewives living in nonsmoking households were the least exposed subjects in this study, showing levels of 32 microg m(-3) RSP, 0.17 microg m(-3) ETS particles, and 0.15 microg m(-3) nicotine. As based upon median levels of ETS particles and nicotine, no group would potentially inhale or be exposed to more than 10 cigarette equivalents per year (CE/y) and the least exposed would inhale less than 1 CE/y. The most highly exposed (90th percentile levels) nonsmokers in this study, who both worked and lived with smokers, would potentially inhale up to 29 CE/y. Overall, the workplace was estimated to contribute between 45% and 49% of the annual exposure to nicotine and ETS particles, respectively. On the basis of determined saliva cotinine concentrations, a misclassification rate of between 1.7% and 2.5% was calculated.
Highest exposures were apparent for office workers both working and living in smoking environments. and our findings suggest a significant contribution to overall ETS particle and nicotine levels from the workplace where smoking takes place. Overall, the rates at which subjects were determined to have misclassified their smoking status in this study were the lowest observed in any of the European cities investigated to date. Clearly, a more sensitive method of analysis for cotinine in body fluids is needed for more accurate determination of the levels expected for nonsmokers.
在捷克共和国布拉格对可吸入悬浮颗粒物(RSP)和环境烟草烟雾(ETS)暴露情况进行评估,通过24小时个人监测确定个人暴露的范围和程度。
从布拉格具有代表性的人群样本中随机选取自我报告的非吸烟者。家庭主妇被归入一组,主要用于评估家庭中的暴露情况,办公室工作人员被归入另一组,用于评估工作场所的贡献。
总共238名随机选取的非吸烟受试者佩戴个人监测器24小时,在其呼吸区域附近采集空气样本。对采集的样本进行RSP、尼古丁、3 - 乙烯基吡啶和ETS颗粒分析(使用紫外线吸收、荧光和茄尼醇测量方法)。还进行了唾液可替宁分析以确认受试者的非吸烟状态。
本研究中暴露程度最高的受试者是那些与吸烟者一起生活和工作的办公室工作人员。这些受试者的RSP时间加权平均暴露浓度中位数为60微克/立方米,ETS颗粒为16微克/立方米,尼古丁为1.6微克/立方米,他们的唾液可替宁水平中位数也最高,为2.4纳克/毫升。生活在无烟家庭的家庭主妇是本研究中暴露程度最低的受试者,其RSP水平为32微克/立方米,ETS颗粒为0.17微克/立方米,尼古丁为0.15微克/立方米。基于ETS颗粒和尼古丁的中位数水平,没有一组每年可能吸入或接触超过10支香烟当量(CE/y),暴露程度最低的组吸入量少于1 CE/y。本研究中与吸烟者一起工作和生活的暴露程度最高(第90百分位数水平)的非吸烟者每年可能吸入多达29 CE/y。总体而言,工作场所估计分别占尼古丁和ETS颗粒年度暴露量的45%至49%。根据测定的唾液可替宁浓度,计算出的错误分类率在1.7%至2.5%之间。
在吸烟环境中工作和生活的办公室工作人员暴露程度最高,我们的研究结果表明,吸烟发生的工作场所对总体ETS颗粒和尼古丁水平有重大贡献。总体而言,本研究中确定受试者错误分类其吸烟状态的发生率是迄今为止在任何被调查的欧洲城市中观察到的最低水平。显然,需要一种更灵敏的体液中可替宁分析方法来更准确地确定非吸烟者预期的水平。