Cheng K I, Tang C S, Chiu S L, Chen T I, Wang C J, Fan K T, Yu K L
Department of Anesthesiology, Kaohsiung Medical College, Taiwan, Republic of China.
Kaohsiung J Med Sci. 1998 Aug;14(8):480-5.
One hundred and twenty-seven children aged 3-6 years were allocated to four groups. All of them received venous cannulation on the dorsum of the hand. On induction, the group L1, L2 and L3 patients received propofol 3 mg/kg mixed with lignocaine 0.15 mg/kg, 0.3 mg/kg, 0.6 mg/kg, respectively. The group T patients received thiopentone 3 mg/kg, then propofol 1.5 mg/kg mixed with lignocaine 0.075 mg/kg. Pain on injection was categorized into two-assessment items (facial expression and limbs withdrawal). The facial expression category were subdivided into none, mild (knit of brows), moderate (grimace), and severe (crying). The withdrawal of limbs was categorized into none, mild (withdrawal of hand), moderate (withdrawal of fore-arm and arm), severe (withdrawal of arm and twisting of body). Patients were monitored using an electrocardiogram, pulse oximeter, autonomic noninvasive blood pressure measuring device and capnography. The patient characteristics did not differ significantly among the four groups. Pain on injection was significantly more frequent in the group L1 patients (81%) compared with the group T (27%) patients. Increasing lignocaine dose reduced the incidence of pain graded as "moderate" or "severe" though there was no significant difference. The incidences of excitatory effect on propofol injection were reduced with increasing lignocaine dose and prior administration of thiopentone but there were no obviously differences among groups. We concluded that thiopentone reduced injection pain on propofol and should be recommended.
127名3至6岁的儿童被分为四组。他们均接受了手背静脉插管。诱导时,L1、L2和L3组患者分别接受3mg/kg丙泊酚与0.15mg/kg、0.3mg/kg、0.6mg/kg利多卡因混合液。T组患者接受3mg/kg硫喷妥钠,然后接受1.5mg/kg丙泊酚与0.075mg/kg利多卡因混合液。注射时的疼痛分为两项评估指标(面部表情和肢体退缩)。面部表情类别分为无、轻度(皱眉)、中度(鬼脸)和重度(哭泣)。肢体退缩分为无、轻度(手部退缩)、中度(前臂和手臂退缩)、重度(手臂退缩和身体扭动)。使用心电图、脉搏血氧仪、无创自主血压测量装置和二氧化碳监测仪对患者进行监测。四组患者的特征无显著差异。与T组(27%)患者相比,L1组患者注射时疼痛明显更频繁(81%)。利多卡因剂量增加可降低“中度”或“重度”疼痛的发生率,尽管无显著差异。随着利多卡因剂量增加和硫喷妥钠的预先给药,丙泊酚注射兴奋效应的发生率降低,但各组之间无明显差异。我们得出结论,硫喷妥钠可减轻丙泊酚注射疼痛,应予以推荐。