van Birgelen A P
National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, Research Triangle Park, NC 27709 USA.
Environ Health Perspect. 1998 Nov;106(11):683-8. doi: 10.1289/ehp.106-1533492.
A dioxinlike compound is a compound that binds to the aryl hydrocarbon (Ah) receptor, results in dioxinlike effects, and bioaccumulates. These are the three factors for including dioxinlike chemicals in the toxic equivalency factor (TEF) concept. Risk assessment of dioxinlike compounds is based on using these TEFs. Hexachlorobenzene (HCB) has all three features and should therefore be included in this TEF concept. Relative potency values express the potency of a specific compound in comparison to 2,3,7, 8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD), the most potent dioxinlike compound, with a relative potency value of 1. For the estimation of the total dioxin activity in an environmental biological sample, the TEF value of a compound is multiplied by the concentration in the specific matrix. This results in a certain amount of toxic equivalents (TEQs) for this compound. The summation of all TEQs in a certain mixture gives the total dioxin activity of this mixture. HCB binds to the Ah receptor about 10,000 times less than TCDD. HCB is also about 10,000 times less potent than TCDD based on in vitro cytochrome P4501A induction and porphyrin accumulation. Using a relative potency value of 0.0001, HCB could add 10-60% to the total TEQ in human milk samples in most countries. In a few countries such as Spain, Slovakia, and the Czech Republic, HCB levels in human milk expressed as TEQ could contribute up to a factor of six to the total TEQ in comparison to the contribution of polychlorinated dioxins, dibenzofurans, and biphenyls together, i.e., up to a daily intake of about 1 ng TEQ/kg for a breast-fed infant. The HCB levels in human milk in these countries are about the same as in India. Biochemical, immunological, and neurological alterations have been observed in infants fed breast milk in countries with relatively low TEQ levels in human milk. Based on the above information, it is clear that HCB should be classified as a dioxinlike compound, that more studies are needed to reduce the uncertainty in the estimation of a relative potency value for HCB, and that epidemiological studies should be undertaken in infants fed breast milk in countries with high HCB exposure levels. Furthermore, measurements of HCB levels in human and environmental samples in conjunction with other dioxinlike compounds is a prerequisite to estimate the total dioxin activity in these samples.
类二噁英化合物是一种能与芳烃(Ah)受体结合、产生类二噁英效应并具有生物累积性的化合物。这三个因素构成了将类二噁英化学物质纳入毒性当量因子(TEF)概念的依据。类二噁英化合物的风险评估就是基于这些TEF值进行的。六氯苯(HCB)具备所有这三个特征,因此应被纳入该TEF概念。相对效力值表示特定化合物相对于最具效力的类二噁英化合物2,3,7,8 - 四氯二苯并 - p - 二噁英(TCDD)的效力,TCDD的相对效力值为1。为估算环境生物样品中的总二噁英活性,将化合物的TEF值乘以特定基质中的浓度。这样就得出该化合物一定量的毒性当量(TEQ)。某一混合物中所有TEQ的总和即为该混合物的总二噁英活性。HCB与Ah受体的结合能力比TCDD弱约10000倍。基于体外细胞色素P4501A诱导和卟啉积累实验,HCB的效力也比TCDD弱约10000倍。使用0.0001的相对效力值,在大多数国家,HCB在母乳样品的总TEQ中所占比例可达10% - 60%。在西班牙、斯洛伐克和捷克共和国等少数国家,母乳中以TEQ表示的HCB含量对总TEQ的贡献与多氯二苯并二噁英、二苯并呋喃和联苯的贡献之和相比,可能高达6倍,即对于母乳喂养的婴儿,每日摄入量约为1 ng TEQ/kg。这些国家母乳中的HCB含量与印度大致相同。在母乳中TEQ水平相对较低的国家,已观察到母乳喂养婴儿出现生化、免疫和神经方面的改变。基于上述信息,很明显HCB应被归类为类二噁英化合物,需要开展更多研究以降低HCB相对效力值估算中的不确定性,并且应对HCB暴露水平高的国家中母乳喂养的婴儿进行流行病学研究。此外,结合其他类二噁英化合物对人体和环境样品中的HCB水平进行测量,是估算这些样品中总二噁英活性的前提条件。