Holden J, O'Donnell S, Brindley J, Miles L
Medical Centre, St Helen's.
Br J Gen Pract. 1998 Jul;48(432):1409-12.
The death of a patient is a significant event that occurs often enough in general practice for it to have the potential to tell us much about the care we provide. There are few large series in the literature and we still know little about the collaborative use of this outcome measure.
To determine the pattern of deaths and potentially preventable factors in our practices.
We completed a standard data collection form after each death in four general practices over a 40-month period. The results were discussed at quarterly meetings.
A total of 1263 deaths occurred among our registered patients during the period of the audit. Preventable factors contributing to deaths were considered to be attributable to: patients (40%): mainly cigarette smoking, poor compliance, and alcohol problems; general practice teams (5%): mainly delayed referral, diagnosis and treatment, and failure to prescribe aspirin to patients with vascular disease; hospitals (6%): mainly delayed diagnosis and perceived treatment problems; the environment (3%): mainly falls, principally resulting in fractured neck of femur.
A simple audit of deaths along the lines that we describe gives important information about the care provided by general practice teams and those in hospital practice. It has both educational value and is a source of ideas for service improvement and further study, particularly when carried out over several years.
患者死亡是常见的重大事件,在全科医疗中经常发生,足以让我们了解所提供的医疗服务情况。文献中大型系列研究较少,我们对这一结果指标的协同使用仍知之甚少。
确定我们诊所的死亡模式及潜在可预防因素。
在40个月期间,我们在四家全科诊所每例患者死亡后填写一份标准数据收集表。结果在季度会议上进行讨论。
在审核期间,我们登记的患者中共有1263例死亡。导致死亡的可预防因素被认为可归因于:患者(40%):主要是吸烟、依从性差和酒精问题;全科医疗团队(5%):主要是转诊、诊断和治疗延迟,以及未给血管疾病患者开阿司匹林;医院(6%):主要是诊断延迟和感知到的治疗问题;环境(3%):主要是跌倒,主要导致股骨颈骨折。
按照我们所描述的方式对死亡情况进行简单审核,可提供有关全科医疗团队和医院医疗服务的重要信息。它既有教育价值,也是服务改进和进一步研究的思路来源,尤其是在多年进行的情况下。