Baker Richard, Sullivan Emma, Camosso-Stefinovic Janette, Rashid Aly, Farooqi Azhar, Blackledge Hanna, Allen Justin
Department of Health Sciences, University of Leicester, UK.
Qual Saf Health Care. 2007 Apr;16(2):84-9. doi: 10.1136/qshc.2006.019885.
To review studies of the use of mortality data in quality and safety improvement in general practice.
Narrative review.
Search of Medline, Embase and CINAHL for articles reporting mortality monitoring or mortality reviews in general practice. The included articles were reported in English and of any study design, excluding case reports and comment pieces. Studies of palliative care and bereavement, and of primary care programmes in developing countries, were excluded.
229 articles were identified in the searches, 65 were identified as potentially relevant and 53 were included in the review. The studies addressed the impact of primary care provision on mortality rates, methods of monitoring mortality, and the role of audit and death registers in quality and safety improvement. General practitioners were interested in using mortality data but reported difficulties in obtaining complete information. There were no experimental studies of the impact of the use of mortality data, and little evidence of long-term systematic initiatives to use mortality data in quality and safety improvement in general practice.
Mortality data are not used systematically in general practice although general practitioners appear interested in the potential of this information in improving quality and safety. Improved systems to provide complete data are needed and experimental studies required to determine the effectiveness of use of the data to improve general practice care.
回顾关于在全科医疗中使用死亡率数据进行质量和安全改进的研究。
叙述性综述。
检索Medline、Embase和CINAHL数据库,查找报告全科医疗中死亡率监测或死亡率审查的文章。纳入的文章需用英文撰写,采用任何研究设计,但不包括病例报告和评论文章。排除姑息治疗和丧亲之痛的研究以及发展中国家的初级保健项目研究。
检索到229篇文章,65篇被确定为可能相关,53篇被纳入综述。这些研究探讨了初级保健服务对死亡率的影响、死亡率监测方法以及审核和死亡登记在质量和安全改进中的作用。全科医生对使用死亡率数据感兴趣,但报告称获取完整信息存在困难。没有关于使用死亡率数据影响的实验研究,也几乎没有证据表明在全科医疗质量和安全改进方面有长期系统地使用死亡率数据的举措。
尽管全科医生似乎对这些信息在提高质量和安全方面的潜力感兴趣,但死亡率数据在全科医疗中并未得到系统使用。需要改进系统以提供完整数据,并开展实验研究来确定使用这些数据改善全科医疗服务的有效性。