Daaleman T P, Frey B
Department of Family Medicine, University of Kansas Medical Center School of Medicine, Kansas City 66160-7370, USA.
Arch Fam Med. 1998 Nov-Dec;7(6):548-53. doi: 10.1001/archfami.7.6.548.
There is a heightened interest in spiritual and religious interventions in clinical settings, an area marked by unease and lack of training by physicians. A potential resource for generalists is specialty consultation and referral services, although little is known about the prevalence and patterns of involvement of clergy or pastoral professionals in patient care.
To identify the prevalence and patterns of physician-directed patient referral to or recommended consultation with clergy or pastoral care providers and to describe attitudinal and demographic variables that can predict referring and nonreferring physicians.
A mailed anonymous survey.
Family physicians in the United States.
Active members of the American Academy of Family Physicians whose self-designated professional activity is direct patient care. Of the 756 randomly selected physicians for participation in the study, 438 (57.9%) responded.
Physician reporting on their attitudes and referral behaviors, including referral frequency, and conditions or reasons for referral or nonreferral to clergy and pastoral care providers.
More than 80% of the physicians reported that they refer or recommend their patients to clergy and pastoral care providers; more than 30% stated that they refer more than 10 times a year. Most physicians (75.5%) chose conditions associated with end-of-life care (ie, bereavement, terminal illness) as reasons for referral. Marital and family counseling were cited by 72.8% of physicians; however, other psychosocial issues, such as depression and mood disorders (38.7%) and substance abuse (19.0%), were less prevalent. Physicians who reported a greater degree of religiosity had a small increased tendency to refer (r = 0.39, P<.05) to these providers. In addition, physicians who were in practice for more than 15 years were more likely to refer to clergy (P<.01).
Most family physicians accept clergy and pastoral professionals in the care of their patients. In medical settings, the providers of religious and spiritual interventions have a larger and more expanded role than previously reported.
临床环境中对精神和宗教干预的兴趣日益浓厚,而这一领域存在不安情绪且医生缺乏相关培训。对于全科医生而言,一个潜在资源是专科会诊和转诊服务,不过对于神职人员或宗教专业人员参与患者护理的普遍性和模式了解甚少。
确定医生指导患者转诊至神职人员或宗教护理提供者或建议会诊的普遍性和模式,并描述能够预测转诊医生和不转诊医生的态度及人口统计学变量。
邮寄匿名调查问卷。
美国的家庭医生。
美国全科医生学会的活跃成员,其自行指定的专业活动为直接的患者护理。在随机选择参与研究的756名医生中,438名(57.9%)做出了回应。
医生报告其态度和转诊行为,包括转诊频率以及转诊或不转诊至神职人员和宗教护理提供者的情况或原因。
超过80%的医生报告称他们会将患者转诊或推荐给神职人员和宗教护理提供者;超过30%的医生表示他们每年转诊超过10次。大多数医生(75.5%)选择与临终关怀相关的情况(如丧亲之痛、晚期疾病)作为转诊原因。72.8%的医生提到婚姻和家庭咨询;然而,其他心理社会问题,如抑郁和情绪障碍(38.7%)以及药物滥用(19.0%),则不太常见。报告宗教信仰程度较高的医生转诊给这些提供者的倾向略有增加(r = 0.39,P <.05)。此外,从业超过15年的医生更有可能转诊给神职人员(P <.01)。
大多数家庭医生认可神职人员和宗教专业人员参与其患者的护理。在医疗环境中,宗教和精神干预的提供者所起的作用比先前报道的更大且范围更广。