Schiepers C, Bormans I, De Roo M
Department of Nuclear Medicine, University Hospital Gasthuisberg, Leuven, Belgium.
Acta Orthop Belg. 1998 Sep;64(3):322-7.
Algoneurodystrophy (AND) is a complex disorder with a wide spectrum of clinical presentations. Patients referred for a work-up of unilateral upper extremity AND were reviewed, and 50 patients were enrolled with sufficient documentation on history, causal event, clinical stage, and final outcome. There were 27 females, 23 males, mean age 44 years. The affected area was: shoulder 5, arm 3, elbow 3, wrist 26 and hand 13. Main precipitating events were fracture, contusion, or prior surgery. Three-phase bone scintigraphy was performed followed by a 2-phase vascular scintigraphy on another day. Typical periarticular uptake on the delayed bone scan was used to diagnose AND. Staging was done with the dynamic phase of the vascular scan. The clinicians diagnosed 30 patients positive for AND, 14 negative, and 6 equivocal. Bone scintigraphy yielded 25 positive, 20 negative, and 5 equivocal scans, i.e. sensitivity 73% and specificity 86%. Of the positive bone scans, 21 had all 3 phases positive, and 16 were concordant on vascular scintigraphy. The remaining 5 vascular scans classified 3 patients in transition (stage I-->II) and 2 in stage II. In other words, in 24% of patients vascular scintigraphy indicated restaging.
dynamic bone scintigraphy is an accurate method to diagnose AND. Vascular scintigraphy changed AND stage in one quarter of the patients. Therefore, a combination of both studies is indicated in the work-up and treatment monitoring of AND.
痛性神经营养不良(AND)是一种临床表现多样的复杂病症。对因单侧上肢AND前来接受检查的患者进行了回顾性研究,纳入了50例有充分病史、病因事件、临床分期及最终结局记录的患者。其中女性27例,男性23例,平均年龄44岁。受累部位为:肩部5例,上臂3例,肘部3例,腕部26例,手部13例。主要诱发事件为骨折、挫伤或既往手术。先行三相骨闪烁扫描,另日再行双相血管闪烁扫描。延迟骨扫描时典型的关节周围摄取用于诊断AND。根据血管扫描的动态期进行分期。临床医生诊断AND阳性30例,阴性14例,可疑6例。骨闪烁扫描结果为阳性25例,阴性20例,可疑5例,即敏感性73%,特异性86%。在阳性骨扫描中,21例三相均为阳性,16例血管闪烁扫描结果一致。其余5例血管扫描将3例患者归为过渡期(I期→II期),2例归为II期。换言之,24%的患者血管闪烁扫描提示需重新分期。
动态骨闪烁扫描是诊断AND的准确方法。血管闪烁扫描使四分之一的患者AND分期发生改变。因此,在AND的检查及治疗监测中,建议联合应用这两种检查。