Duijm L E, Guit G L, Hendriks J H, Zaat J O, Mali W P
Department of Radiology, Kennemer Gasthuis Locatie Elisabeth Gasthuis, 2035 RC Haarlem, Netherlands.
BMJ. 1998 Nov 28;317(7171):1492-5. doi: 10.1136/bmj.317.7171.1492.
To determine the value of breast imaging in patients with localised or diffuse pain in the breast in whom physical examination shows no abnormalities.
Observational follow up study.
Radiology department of a teaching hospital in the Netherlands.
Altogether 987 women referred for radiological breast imaging because of pain alone and a control group of 987 asymptomatic women referred for a screening mammogram.
Correlation of the radiological findings with clinical and pathological findings over two years of follow up.
Radiological examination of the painful breast(s) showed the following: normal findings in 854 (86.5%) women, benign abnormalities in 85 (8.6%; mainly small cysts or mastopathy), abnormalities that were probably benign in 36 (3.6%), suspicious findings in 8 (0.8%), and malignancy in 4 (0.4%). Biopsy of the painful area was performed in 10 of the 939 women with normal findings or benign abnormalities, in two of 36 women with radiological abnormalities that were probably benign, and in all women with suspicious or malignant findings. Only the four lesions that had been classified radiologically as malignant were found to be malignant at surgery. The prevalence of breast cancer was similar in symptomatic and control women.
Breast imaging in women who present with pain alone is of value only in providing reassurance--no abnormalities are usually found in the painful area, radiological abnormalities classified as benign do not generally have any clinical consequences, and the prevalence of cancer is low in these women. Biopsy of the painful area should be performed only where radiological findings are suspicious.
确定在体格检查未发现异常的情况下,乳腺影像学检查对有局限性或弥漫性乳腺疼痛患者的价值。
观察性随访研究。
荷兰一家教学医院的放射科。
总共987名因单纯疼痛而接受乳腺影像学检查的女性,以及987名接受筛查性乳房X光检查的无症状女性作为对照组。
随访两年期间影像学检查结果与临床及病理检查结果的相关性。
对疼痛乳腺的影像学检查显示如下情况:854名(86.5%)女性检查结果正常,85名(8.6%)有良性异常(主要为小囊肿或乳腺病),36名(3.6%)异常可能为良性,8名(0.8%)有可疑发现,4名(0.4%)为恶性。939名检查结果正常或有良性异常的女性中有10名、36名影像学异常可能为良性的女性中有2名,以及所有有可疑或恶性发现的女性均对疼痛部位进行了活检。手术中仅发现4例影像学分类为恶性的病变为恶性。有症状女性和对照女性的乳腺癌患病率相似。
仅因疼痛就诊的女性进行乳腺影像学检查的价值仅在于提供安慰——疼痛部位通常未发现异常,分类为良性的影像学异常一般无临床后果,这些女性的癌症患病率较低。仅在影像学检查结果可疑时才应对疼痛部位进行活检。