Gothelf D, Apter A, Brand-Gothelf A, Offer N, Ofek H, Tyano S, Pfeffer C R
Department of Psychiatry, Tel Aviv University, Israel.
J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 1998 Dec;37(12):1279-86. doi: 10.1097/00004583-199812000-00011.
To investigate the relationship between components of death concept (preoccupation with death, death as a pleasant state, and death as final) and suicidal behavior in adolescents.
The death concepts of 51 suicidal inpatients, 102 nonsuicidal inpatients, 36 emergency room suicidal subjects, and 81 normal controls were compared using Pfeffer's Child Suicide Potential Scale. In addition, the IQ level as well as emotions that potentially influence the death concept were measured.
Both groups of suicidal adolescents evaluated death as more pleasant than the nonsuicidal groups. All the study groups equally perceived death as a final state. Suicidal inpatients were more preoccupied with death than nonsuicidal inpatients, but surprisingly among all study groups, including normal controls, the emergency room suicidal subjects were the least preoccupied with death. Partialing out depression, anxiety, and aggression specifically augmented the association between preoccupation with death and suicidality. Thus the relationship between death concept and suicidality appears to be a direct one. No correlation was found between suicidality and intelligence level.
Elements of death concept distinguish suicidal from nonsuicidal as well as between hospitalized versus nonhospitalized suicidal adolescents. Thus the death concept evaluation is potentially valuable in the assessment of adolescents with a high risk for suicide.
探讨青少年死亡观念的组成部分(对死亡的关注、将死亡视为愉悦状态、将死亡视为终结)与自杀行为之间的关系。
使用菲弗儿童自杀倾向量表,比较51名自杀住院青少年、102名非自杀住院青少年、36名急诊室自杀青少年和81名正常对照者的死亡观念。此外,还测量了智商水平以及可能影响死亡观念的情绪。
两组自杀青少年都比非自杀组更倾向于将死亡视为愉悦状态。所有研究组都同样将死亡视为一种终结状态。自杀住院青少年比非自杀住院青少年更关注死亡,但令人惊讶的是,在所有研究组中,包括正常对照者,急诊室自杀青少年对死亡的关注最少。排除抑郁、焦虑和攻击性后,对死亡的关注与自杀倾向之间的关联尤其增强。因此,死亡观念与自杀倾向之间的关系似乎是直接的。未发现自杀倾向与智力水平之间存在相关性。
死亡观念的要素可区分自杀青少年与非自杀青少年,以及住院自杀青少年与非住院自杀青少年。因此,死亡观念评估在评估自杀风险高的青少年时可能具有重要价值。