Liu P F, Krestin G P, Huch R A, Göhde S C, Caduff R F, Debatin J F
Zurich University Hospital, Switzerland.
Eur Radiol. 1998;8(8):1433-40. doi: 10.1007/s003300050569.
The aim of this study was to compare the diagnostic performance of contrast-enhanced fast multiplanar gradient-echo (GRE) and T2-weighted fast spin-echo (FSE) image sets in the assessment of uterus, cervix, and vagina. Fast (up to 20 contiguous sections in 23 s) multiplanar GRE and FSE images of 45 patients referred for imaging of the female pelvis were evaluated retrospectively with regard to overall image quality and the ability to detect normal anatomic structures, as well as lesion conspicuity. Results were compared with histologic findings (n = 29) or clinical follow-up. Furthermore, a quantitative assessment of contrast-to-noise ratios among normal uterine and cervical structures as well as uterine lesions was performed for both sequences. On GRE images, uterine and cervical differentiation was best seen on the image sets acquired 15 and 60 s following contrast enhancement and results were significantly better compared with delayed images (p < 0.05). Delineation of the junctional zone was significantly (p < 0.05) better on FSE compared with GRE images; no significant difference was seen for the other anatomic structures. Overall image quality of GRE and FSE images was similar. Sensitivity for lesion detection based on both GRE and FSE images was 96% with a sensitivity of 93% for GRE, and 81% for FSE images alone, respectively. Using the extended McNemar chi 2 test, the difference in diagnostic performance between FSE and GRE revealed no significant difference, whereas the combination of both techniques performed better than FSE imaging alone (p < 0.05). The presented data suggest that dynamic contrast-enhanced GRE imaging should be part of an MR examination of the female pelvis. Combined GRE and FSE imaging provide an excellent sensitivity in the assessment of uterine and vaginal pathologies.
本研究的目的是比较对比增强快速多平面梯度回波(GRE)和T2加权快速自旋回波(FSE)图像集在评估子宫、宫颈和阴道方面的诊断性能。回顾性评估了45例因女性盆腔成像而转诊患者的快速(23秒内多达20个连续切片)多平面GRE和FSE图像的整体图像质量、检测正常解剖结构的能力以及病变的清晰度。将结果与组织学结果(n = 29)或临床随访结果进行比较。此外,对两种序列的正常子宫和宫颈结构以及子宫病变之间的对比噪声比进行了定量评估。在GRE图像上,子宫和宫颈的区分在对比增强后15秒和60秒获取的图像集上显示最佳,与延迟图像相比结果显著更好(p < 0.05)。与GRE图像相比,FSE图像上结合带的描绘明显更好(p < 0.05);其他解剖结构未见显著差异。GRE和FSE图像的整体图像质量相似。基于GRE和FSE图像的病变检测敏感性均为96%,其中GRE图像单独的敏感性为93%,FSE图像单独的敏感性为81%。使用扩展的McNemar卡方检验,FSE和GRE之间的诊断性能差异无显著差异,而两种技术的联合应用比单独的FSE成像表现更好(p < 0.05)。所呈现的数据表明,动态对比增强GRE成像应成为女性盆腔磁共振检查的一部分。GRE和FSE联合成像在评估子宫和阴道病变方面具有出色的敏感性。