Lukasz S, Mühlbauer R, Faber S, Englmeier K H, Reiser M, Eckstein F
Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität, München.
Ann Anat. 1998 Dec;180(6):487-93.
The objective of the present study was to determine differences in the normal knee joint cartilage volume of males and females, the analysis of the percentage distribution of the cartilage tissue onto the various joint surfaces, and the determination of the relationship between the cartilage volume, the body weight, and the tibial head diameter. We examined the knee joints of nine healthy men and nine women with a low level of physical activity. The cartilage volume was assessed with magnetic resonance imaging, applying a fat-suppressed gradient-echo sequence with a resolution of 2 x 0.31 x 0.31 mm3 and 3D image reconstruction. In the men, the absolute volumes of the femur and tibia, but not those of the patella, were significantly higher than in the women. The differences between the sexes were considerably lower after normalisation to the body weight and the tibial head diameter and were no more statistically significant. The interindividual variability was reduced after normalisation to these two parameters, the body weight being more effective. We did not observe sex-specific differences in the percentage of the total cartilage volume taken up by the various joint surfaces. Our results suggest that, in young individuals without cartilage lesions, there exist sex-specific differences of the cartilage volume in the knee joint. However, these can be explained in terms of general differences in body constitution (body weight and bone size), without further significant influences of the sex. The knowledge of the normal, sex-specific cartilage volume is relevant when attempting to estimate the amount of tissue loss at the time at which symptoms occur in a patient with degenerative joint disease.
本研究的目的是确定男性和女性正常膝关节软骨体积的差异,分析软骨组织在各个关节表面的百分比分布,并确定软骨体积、体重和胫骨头直径之间的关系。我们检查了9名身体活动水平较低的健康男性和9名健康女性的膝关节。采用脂肪抑制梯度回波序列,分辨率为2×0.31×0.31mm³,并进行三维图像重建,通过磁共振成像评估软骨体积。男性股骨和胫骨的绝对体积显著高于女性,但髌骨的绝对体积并非如此。在根据体重和胫骨头直径进行归一化后,两性之间的差异显著降低,不再具有统计学意义。在根据这两个参数进行归一化后,个体间变异性降低,体重的影响更为显著。我们没有观察到各个关节表面占总软骨体积百分比的性别差异。我们的结果表明,在没有软骨损伤的年轻个体中,膝关节软骨体积存在性别差异。然而,这些差异可以用身体构成(体重和骨骼大小)的一般差异来解释,而没有性别的进一步显著影响。在试图估计退行性关节病患者出现症状时的组织损失量时,了解正常的、性别特异性的软骨体积是相关的。