Tschauner C, Hofmann S, Urban M, Jaros S, Eder T, Czerny C
Orthopädische Abteilung, SMZ Ost-Donauspital, Wien.
Orthopade. 1998 Nov;27(11):765-71.
Concomitant pathologies (labral lesions, intra-/extra-osseous ganglia and stress bone marrow edema) in adult residual hip dysplasia (RHD) might influence the outcome of conservative hip surgery. The aim of our prospective clinical study was to assess the value of preoperative MR arthrography in diagnosing concomitant lesions and in making surgical decisions in RHD. The first 37 consecutive patients with a minimum follow-up of 18 months have been analysed. All 37 patients presented RHD with the clinical symptomatology of labral lesions and underwent routine preoperative MRA. According to clinical, radiological and MR arthrographical criteria, these 37 patients were subdivided into four therapeutic subgroups: (1) reorientation of the acetabulum using the Tönnis triple pelvic osteotomy (TPO); (2) intertrochanteric varisation osteotomy (IVO); (3) palliative decompression with only symptomatic partial resection of the torn labrum (PALL); (4) primary total hip replacement (TEP). Based on the preliminary clinical and radiological outcomes of these four subgroups, the following conclusions can be drawn: labral lesions are considered to be a sign of chronic joint instability. Therefore, acetabular malorientation should be corrected by redirectional osteotomy of the acetabulum (TPO-subgroup) even in low grades of RHD if labral lesions are present. "Palliative" labral resections without corrective osteotomy (PALL subgroup) in secondary osteoarthritis due to RHD are definitively obsolete, because they rapidly progress to severe osteoarthritis due to surgically accelerated joint instability. In RHD with highly osteoarthritic hip joints and concomitant lesions, one should not hesitate to perform primary THR even in young patients.
成人残留性髋关节发育不良(RHD)中的合并病变(盂唇损伤、骨内/外腱鞘囊肿和应力性骨髓水肿)可能会影响保守性髋关节手术的疗效。我们前瞻性临床研究的目的是评估术前磁共振关节造影在诊断RHD合并病变及制定手术决策方面的价值。已对连续37例患者进行分析,其最短随访时间为18个月。所有37例患者均表现为RHD并伴有盂唇损伤的临床症状,且均接受了术前常规磁共振关节造影(MRA)检查。根据临床、放射学和磁共振关节造影标准,将这37例患者分为四个治疗亚组:(1)采用托尼斯三联骨盆截骨术(TPO)进行髋臼重新定向;(2)转子间内翻截骨术(IVO);(3)仅对撕裂的盂唇进行有症状的部分切除的姑息性减压术(PALL);(4)初次全髋关节置换术(TEP)。基于这四个亚组的初步临床和放射学结果,可得出以下结论:盂唇损伤被认为是慢性关节不稳定的一个迹象。因此,如果存在盂唇损伤,即使是低度RHD,也应通过髋臼重新定向截骨术(TPO亚组)纠正髋臼方向异常。由于RHD导致继发性骨关节炎时,不进行矫正截骨术的“姑息性”盂唇切除术(PALL亚组)已完全过时,因为手术加速了关节不稳定,此类手术会迅速发展为严重骨关节炎。对于患有高度骨关节炎性髋关节且伴有合并病变的RHD患者,即使是年轻患者,也应毫不犹豫地进行初次全髋关节置换术。