Lim H C, Tan C B, Goh L G, Ling S L
Geylang Polyclinic, Singapore.
Singapore Med J. 1998 Sep;39(9):390-5.
BACKGROUND/AIM OF STUDY: Patient complaints are indications of their dissatisfaction with the service received. With increasing patient expectations, we need to address this issue for a more satisfying relationship between healthcare provider and user. The objective of this study was to analyse the basis of patients' complaints and to make recommendations to reduce its incidence.
This is a retrospective descriptive study of all complaints to the Family Health Service between January 1994 and December 1995. All complaints, investigations and replies to complainants were examined and analysed by the authors to determine the reasons for complaints and their justification.
There were 226 complaint cases out of 5,620,834 attendances in two years, giving the complaints rate of 4 per 100,000 attendances per year. The complaint rate was highest for the 20-59-year age group and lowest in the 10-19-year age group (3.7 and 2.0 per 100,000 attendances respectively). Sixty-four percent of complaints were verbal and the rest were written. Forty-seven percent of the complaints were made by relatives and 46% were self-complaints. The main reasons for complaints were related to attitude/conduct (28.8%), professional skills (17.8%), patient expectations (16.2%), waiting time (10.0%) and communication (7.8%). Forty-three percent of complaints were evaluated as justifiable, 38% not justifiable and 19% inconclusive. There were no particular sex or ethnic group differences.
The rate of complaints in Family Health Service was low. Healthcare personnel need to pay attention to areas related to attitude/conduct, professional skills, patient expectations, waiting time and communication.
研究背景/目的:患者投诉表明他们对所接受的服务不满意。随着患者期望的不断提高,我们需要解决这个问题,以建立医疗服务提供者与使用者之间更令人满意的关系。本研究的目的是分析患者投诉的原因,并提出减少投诉发生率的建议。
这是一项对1994年1月至1995年12月期间向家庭健康服务机构提出的所有投诉进行的回顾性描述性研究。作者对所有投诉、调查及给投诉者的回复进行了检查和分析,以确定投诉原因及其合理性。
两年内5,620,834次就诊中有226起投诉案例,投诉率为每年每100,000次就诊4起。投诉率在20 - 59岁年龄组最高,在10 - 19岁年龄组最低(分别为每100,000次就诊3.7起和2.0起)。64%的投诉是口头的,其余是书面的。47%的投诉由亲属提出,46%是患者本人投诉。投诉的主要原因与态度/行为(28.8%)、专业技能(17.8%)、患者期望(16.2%)、等待时间(10.0%)和沟通(7.8%)有关。43%的投诉被评估为合理,38%不合理,19%无定论。不存在特定的性别或种族差异。
家庭健康服务中的投诉率较低。医护人员需要关注与态度/行为、专业技能、患者期望、等待时间和沟通相关的领域。