VandeCreek L, Rogers E, Lester J
HealthCare Chaplaincy, New York, NY, USA.
Altern Ther Health Med. 1999 Jan;5(1):71-6.
Breast cancer is the second largest cause of cancer death among women in the United States. Given the fear associated with its morbidity and mortality, patients might seek a variety of alternative treatments. No careful description of breast cancer patients' interest in or use of these therapies appears to exist.
To create a profile that describes interest in and use of a wide variety of alternative therapies available to breast cancer outpatients; to gather data concerning related issues such as the number of appointments for these therapies, their cost, and reimbursement patterns; and to compare these findings with a published profile of the general public.
An interview gauging patients' interest in and use of alternative treatments followed by 2 questionnaires concerning (1) mental adjustment to the cancer experience and (2) personal growth in response to the encounter with cancer.
Suburban breast cancer clinic in a Midwestern university medical center.
112 female breast cancer outpatients.
Rankings of interest in and use of alternative treatments by the patients interviewed.
The 3 most frequently used alternative therapies were prayer (76%), exercise (38%), and spiritual healing (29%). Comparison with the general public profiles revealed that breast cancer patients more frequently used 17 specific alternative therapies. The largest increases were found in the use of prayer (51% increase), spiritual healing (25% increase), and megavitamins (23% increase). Only chiropractic was used substantially more often among the general population.
Breast cancer outpatients involved in conventional treatment are more likely to use a wide range of alternative therapies than is the general public. It is likely that the mortality and morbidity associated with breast cancer motivates this increased use.
乳腺癌是美国女性癌症死亡的第二大原因。鉴于其发病率和死亡率令人恐惧,患者可能会寻求各种替代疗法。目前似乎没有对乳腺癌患者对这些疗法的兴趣或使用情况进行详细描述。
创建一个描述乳腺癌门诊患者对多种替代疗法的兴趣和使用情况的概况;收集有关这些疗法的预约次数、费用和报销模式等相关问题的数据;并将这些结果与已发表的普通公众概况进行比较。
通过访谈评估患者对替代疗法的兴趣和使用情况,随后进行两份问卷,一份关于(1)对癌症经历的心理调适,另一份关于(2)因患癌而产生的个人成长。
中西部大学医学中心的郊区乳腺癌诊所。
112名女性乳腺癌门诊患者。
接受访谈患者对替代疗法的兴趣和使用情况排名。
最常用的三种替代疗法是祈祷(76%)、锻炼(38%)和灵性疗愈(29%)。与普通公众概况的比较显示,乳腺癌患者更频繁地使用17种特定的替代疗法。使用增加最多的是祈祷(增加51%)、灵性疗愈(增加25%)和多种维生素(增加23%)。只有脊椎按摩疗法在普通人群中的使用频率明显更高。
与普通公众相比,接受传统治疗的乳腺癌门诊患者更有可能使用多种替代疗法。与乳腺癌相关的死亡率和发病率可能促使了这种使用的增加。