Taki K, Kato H, Hirahara K, Ito Y
Department of Emergency Medicine, Saga Medical College, Japan.
Nihon Hoigaku Zasshi. 1998 Aug;52(4):223-6.
We evaluated the diagnoses noted on the medical records of 275 patients admitted to Saga Medical College Hospital during the six-year period 1990-1995: 245 patients with cardiopulmonary arrest on arrival (CPAOA) and 30 patients with cardiopulmonary arrest occurring in the emergency room (CPAER). The most frequent cause of CPAOA was heart disease, and the next frequent cause was respiratory disease. In the CPAER patients, the most frequent cause was heart disease, while the next frequent was acute aortic dissection. There were discrepancies in the respective causes of cardiac arrest between the CPAOA and CPAER patients, which was probably due to difficulty in diagnosis in the emergency room. In the emergency room, the cardiopulmonary resuscitation is the first treatment to be performed for CPAOA, the examination for the cause of cardiac arrest is the next followed after the heart beating. However, the cause of cardiac arrest can not be diagnosed in the emergency room for the CPAOA patients without the successful resuscitation, because the examinations for the cause of cardiac arrest can not be performed for the patients without beating heart in the emergency room. Therefore, it is concluded that there exists a need to improve the training for finding out the abnormal death with the inspection and the medico-legal autopsy. It may be suggested that the training system of forensic medicine is ideal for clinical physician who can study the decision of the diseases ranging from toxicosis to acute cardiopulmonary arrest in both the emergency and the forensic medicine.
我们评估了1990年至1995年这六年期间入住佐贺医科大学医院的275例患者的病历诊断情况:245例患者入院时发生心肺骤停(CPAOA),30例患者在急诊室发生心肺骤停(CPAER)。CPAOA最常见的病因是心脏病,其次是呼吸系统疾病。在CPAER患者中,最常见的病因是心脏病,其次是急性主动脉夹层。CPAOA和CPAER患者心脏骤停的各自病因存在差异,这可能是由于急诊室诊断困难所致。在急诊室,对于CPAOA患者,心肺复苏是首先进行的治疗,心脏骤停病因检查是在心脏恢复跳动后进行的下一步检查。然而,对于未成功复苏的CPAOA患者,在急诊室无法诊断心脏骤停的病因,因为在急诊室无法对无心跳的患者进行心脏骤停病因检查。因此,得出结论认为,有必要改进通过检查和法医学尸检来查明异常死亡情况的培训。可以建议,法医学培训体系对于临床医生来说是理想的,临床医生可以在急诊医学和法医学领域研究从中毒到急性心肺骤停等疾病的诊断。