Kavoussi R J, Coccaro E F
Department of Psychiatry, MCP-Hahnemann School of Medicine, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
J Clin Psychiatry. 1998 Dec;59(12):676-80. doi: 10.4088/jcp.v59n1206.
Divalproex sodium, an anticonvulsant and antimanic agent, has recently been studied for its antiaggressive effects in patients with brain injuries, dementia, and borderline personality disorder. Since patients with other personality disorders also exhibit impulsive aggressive behavior, we conducted a preliminary open-label trial of divalproex sodium as a treatment for irritability and aggression in patients with a variety of personality disorders.
Ten patients meeting DSM-IV criteria for at least one personality disorder were treated with divalproex sodium in an 8-week open clinical trial. All patients had failed a trial of a selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI). Divalproex sodium was increased as tolerated using a flexible dosing schedule. Clinician ratings for impulsive aggressive behavior and irritability were made every 2 weeks using the modified Overt Aggression Scale (OAS-M).
Six of 8 completers reported significant decreases in irritability (p = .003) and impulsive aggressive behavior (p = .019). For the entire sample, improvement on OAS-M irritability and overt aggression scores was noted by the end of 4 weeks and continued to occur through week 8.
This study suggests that divalproex sodium is an effective treatment for impulsive aggressive behavior in some patients with personality disorder who fail to respond to other antiaggressive agents (i.e., SSRIs). Controlled studies are needed to determine which patients are most likely to benefit from divalproex sodium and to evaluate the differential effectiveness of various agents in reducing impulsive aggressive behavior.
丙戊酸二钠,一种抗惊厥和抗躁狂药物,最近被研究用于治疗脑损伤、痴呆和边缘性人格障碍患者的攻击性行为。由于其他人格障碍患者也表现出冲动攻击行为,我们开展了一项初步的开放标签试验,以研究丙戊酸二钠对各种人格障碍患者的易怒和攻击行为的治疗效果。
在一项为期8周的开放临床试验中,对10名符合DSM-IV标准的至少一种人格障碍患者使用丙戊酸二钠进行治疗。所有患者使用选择性5-羟色胺再摄取抑制剂(SSRI)治疗均无效。根据耐受情况,采用灵活的给药方案增加丙戊酸二钠剂量。每2周使用改良的外显攻击量表(OAS-M)对冲动攻击行为和易怒程度进行临床评分。
8名完成试验的患者中有6名报告易怒程度(p = .003)和冲动攻击行为(p = .019)显著降低。对于整个样本,在4周结束时OAS-M易怒和外显攻击得分有所改善,并持续到第8周。
本研究表明,丙戊酸二钠对一些人格障碍患者的冲动攻击行为有效,这些患者对其他抗攻击药物(即SSRI)无反应。需要进行对照研究,以确定哪些患者最可能从丙戊酸二钠中获益,并评估各种药物在减少冲动攻击行为方面的差异有效性。