Roth A C, Reid J C, Concannon M
School of Medicine, University of Missouri, Columbia, USA.
Proc AMIA Symp. 1998:917-20.
The use of digital wound images would allow remote consultation between patients, physicians, or other caregivers over the Internet. To evaluate the efficacy and validity of digital images for assessment of wounds, we compared the ability and reliability of surgeons to diagnose and make treatment suggestions using either digital or slide images of several types of wounds. Twenty-four wound images on 35-mm slides were selected for use in this study. Each slide image was digitized at 24-bit color with a resolution of 640 pixels horizontal by 425 pixels vertical, and stored as a JPEG file. Six physicians, of varying experience, examined the images, first in digital format and then later in the original slide form. Each observer assessed each wound for condition and possible treatment options by filling out a questionnaire using a series of yes/no questions. For all observers, there was an 87% agreement of answers between digital and slide images (p = 0.004). The agreement between the digital and slide images was also measured for each individual observer using a kappa coefficient. The agreement kappa correlated with the experience of the observer, with the kappa values ranging from greater than 0.8 (almost perfect agreement) for an experienced woundcare professional to just greater than 0.5 (moderate agreement) for a surgical intern. With this study, we have demonstrated the feasibility of distance wound consultation using digital images of a quality consistent with consumer-grade digital photography.
使用数字伤口图像可实现患者、医生或其他护理人员通过互联网进行远程会诊。为了评估数字图像在伤口评估中的有效性和准确性,我们比较了外科医生使用几种伤口的数字图像或幻灯片图像进行诊断和提出治疗建议的能力及可靠性。本研究选用了35毫米幻灯片上的24张伤口图像。每张幻灯片图像以24位颜色数字化,水平分辨率为640像素,垂直分辨率为425像素,并存储为JPEG文件。六位经验各异的医生先以数字格式检查图像,然后再以原始幻灯片形式检查。每位观察者通过填写一份使用一系列“是/否”问题的问卷,对每个伤口的状况和可能的治疗方案进行评估。对于所有观察者而言,数字图像和幻灯片图像的答案一致性为87%(p = 0.004)。还使用kappa系数对每位个体观察者的数字图像和幻灯片图像之间的一致性进行了测量。一致性kappa与观察者的经验相关,kappa值范围从经验丰富的伤口护理专业人员的大于0.8(几乎完全一致)到外科实习生的略大于0.5(中度一致)。通过这项研究,我们证明了使用与消费级数字摄影质量一致的数字图像进行远程伤口会诊的可行性。